I voted 2.
2 for the art.
It was solid. The art was great on Batman and while the plot was interesting it had only passable execution. I think that's my major complaint with Snyder, too often he falls into the "Nice idea, shame about the execution" trap. It happened with Court of Owls, and with Swamp Thing. The ending just sort of fizzles out.
Still, I hope the fracturing on the family has ramifications and that we see some pay off down the line. Batman and Robin #17 served as an excellent epilogue in that respect.
8/10 this story is set to have ramifications long term and I like the way it portrayed the Joker. The last issue was leaked before I bought it and thought from the spoilers it was a downer but actually reading the issue I got exactly where Synder was coming from.
There is only one main stream comic company that actually takes its fans seriously and delivers and thats DC.
It wasn't bad by any means, just very overrated and fairly generic as far as Joker stories go and had that underwhelming ending. I'm thinking its a 6.
I'd just like to point out that 97% of voters here think DotF was overrated to some degree since it's been getting perfect 10/10s or 5/5s every single issue from IGN, Comicvine, iFanboy, CBR etc.
vote for 9.
i wanted to go for 7..gave 2 more points out of liking the arc overall.
What an absolutely garbage ending...I thought things were going to be as good as the finish to the movie Hannibal. Instead it was only an updated version of the Killing Joke.
I voted 4.
"Make yourself comfortable, I haven’t time to attend to it." - With these words, a legend was born.
I gave it a solid 8 in the other poll and then same here.
Current Top Ten Comics: Earth 2, Red Hood and the Outlaws, Talon, X-Men, Batman/Superman, Batman '66, Young Avengers, Larfleeze, Nightwing, Flash
I'd give it a 4. I felt the story itself was mediocre and uninspired, but the craft across the books was mostly consistant. Just a slightly a less than average storyline even for a crossover.
i gave it an 8, too much symbolism for my liking, and the dialogue felt weird at some points. i'm usually ok with snyder's writing, but in this arc it was capullo's amazing art that drives the overall story for me..
Re-reading it. I gave it a 2. Hopeful promises and events just not coming to pass. All rather lackluster.
Behold, I shall be a blight upon the land, and everything I touch shall wither and die!
Hmm, looks like the majority feel it's a better than average story, by roughly a 2-to-1 margin.
I knew something had to be screwy with that first poll, though darned if I can figure out how it happened.
Co-moderator, CBR Batman Forum
Superhero Popularity Study
New and improved second poll is up!
Gave it a 7 out of 10. Not a bad story - but not the best. Had some strong moments, but the end was a bit of a let down.
i thought it was pretty mediocre in the end. between the Court of Owls and this, i'm really starting to get bored with these monster story arcs that drag on way too long and deliver conclusions that, well, just don't deliver.
don't wanna be too harsh as i love Snyder. i thought Severed as well as his Detective Comics run were some of the best comics i've read in years. and sure, some issues of his Batman and Swamp Thing runs have been top notch too, but... i don't know. maybe he's starting to feel the pressure a little bit? or maybe he's just spreading himself too thin lately.