Now that I think about it, Bogdanove and Mahnke are serious contenders too.
AAAGGHHHH my head spins at all the choices!!!
I couldn't pick a favorite \S/ artist at gun point to save Aquacatlungfish's life.
José Luis García-López gets my vote, btw. If only he got to have the longevity on the character that Swan was afforded. A dark horse contender for me would be Tom Grummett. Incredibly underrated Superman artist in my opinion.
Last edited by Sacred Knight; 02-10-2013 at 04:13 PM.
Different strokes, I guess. I always hated Bogdanove's disproportional bodies and constipated, teeth-gritting faces. He was really bad at drawing hair, too. I remember back in the day when Supes had four monthly titles and would routinely do crossovers. Because of Bogdanove, Superman: The Man of Steel was always the worst of the four titles and a real choir for me to get through, but I'd make myself read it anyway just to get the complete story.
Dan Jurgens has always been my favorite Superman artist. Even his New 52 stuff was really good and shows he's still got a flair for the character after all these years.
Last edited by Memphis Raines; 02-10-2013 at 04:22 PM.
Jurgens was a fav back in his legion days but he got really stiff by the 90's for my tastes. During the triangle Era, my favs were Bog and Grummet, then Jurgens and least of all was that guy on Action. Action Comics was to me what Man of Steel was to you, so I can totally relate to struggling through the triangle era like that.
Amen, brother, good times.
The best Superman artist is the underrated Rob Liefeld:
Joking aside, my choice is Gil Kane:
Last edited by the Sun God; 02-10-2013 at 04:40 PM.
Alex Ross followed by Gary Frank IMO.
Pull-list: Action Comics, Batman, Superior Spider-Man, The Flash, Superman, Batman/Superman, Superman/WW, Superman Unchained, Earth-2, Harley Quinn, Astro City, Detective Comics
Toughest choice for me to make. There are so many great artists who've done the character...and so many utter hacks who should never have been allowed anywhere near him. Pinning it down to one guy who does it better than anyone else is unbelievably hard.
But if I had to choose one guy who does the best Superman of the whole bunch, that honor has to go to one of the best all-around artists DC ever had, the great Tom Grummett:
For me, it doesn't get better than this. (And as an added bonus, I own the Fleischer Superman art he did.)
Last edited by King Krypton; 02-10-2013 at 05:59 PM.
Either Curt Swan or whoever did the model sheet for the Fleischer Studios animated version (that strikes me as something I should know, any help?)
Last edited by Memphis Raines; 02-10-2013 at 06:15 PM.