Superior or Avenging??

[Russell]

I think Scarlet Spider is very, very good indeed; I would have to put Daredevil as my personal favorite of the last year or two though. Incredibly consistent and brilliant writing from Waid and for a title that had and lost both Marcos Martin and Paolo Rivera on art, they haven't missed a bit with the fantastic job that Chris Samnee has done in stepping up. But I put both Amazing Spider-Man and Scarlet Spider not far behind Daredevil right now for my favorite comic being produced at the moment (throw in Scott Snyder's "Batman" and there's my Top 5!).

I enjoyed DD, but gave up for financial reasons and because other characters interest me more. I've also never read Hawkeye despite the praise. My top 5 at the moment:
1. Scarlet Spider
2. Thor God of Thunder
3. Amazing/Superior
4. Batman
5. Justice League

Very close between 3 and 4 (I guess this answers the thread for me), 1 is ahead of 2 easily which is ahead if 3 and 4. JL rose because aquaman dropped of late as did superman since hel on earth and ac for a while.

[oldschool]

I enjoyed DD, but gave up for financial reasons and because other characters interest me more. I've also never read Hawkeye despite the praise. My top 5 at the moment:
1. Scarlet Spider
2. Thor God of Thunder
3. Amazing/Superior
4. Batman
5. Justice League

Very close between 3 and 4 (I guess this answers the thread for me), 1 is ahead of 2 easily which is ahead if 3 and 4. JL rose because aquaman dropped of late as did superman since hel on earth and ac for a while.

I have not read Hawkeye either but have heard nothing but praise; I suppose I should give it a whirl!

[The-Rhino]

There has been one issue of each. Not nearly enough information to come to a solid conclusion. I liked two stories. I read Avenging yesterday so that is freshest in my mind, so I think I will go with that one (until I read Superior #2). Its the John Zaller theory of survey response applied to comicbook forums. !!!1

[Zombies8MyDingo]

Avenging so far, I love Chris Yost's writing of that and Scarlet Spider alot more than Dan Slott's. Even just the preview for issue 2 of Superior highlighted this for me.

[Russell]

I have not read Hawkeye either but have heard nothing but praise; I suppose I should give it a whirl!

Yeah I'm thinking the same. although I'm not much of a fan.

I'd have included KD's Avengers Assemble in my top 5, in place of Justice League but it looks like she's off the book after three issues.

I think Chris Yost and Kelly Sue Deconnick are the best two writers Marvel employes at the moment (followed by Slott)

[ViewtifulJC]

Hawkeye is currently the best book Marvel publishes. When the trade comes out and you can get all those glorious David Aja/Javier Paluido pages, you won't be disappointed or your money back(for bad taste)

[Raptor]

Scarlet Spider

Then Avenging

Then Superior

I'm a huge Yost fan, so I guess I'm biased.

[MorningMoon]

Yeah I'm thinking the same. although I'm not much of a fan.

I'd have included KD's Avengers Assemble in my top 5, in place of Justice League but it looks like she's off the book after three issues.

I think Chris Yost and Kelly Sue Deconnick are the best two writers Marvel employes at the moment (followed by Slott)

Wha? where'd you hear that, she's still the writer.

[oldschool]

Wha? where'd you hear that, she's still the writer.

I thought so too.....gotta find the solicits to confirm but I thought (and hope) that she is still writing Avengers Assemble.

[Lars C]

When has Spidey been in Scarlet Spider?


Anyway, I'm going to hold my vote off until I've read a few issues of each. I loved both of them though, so it might be a tough choice.

Well, Kaine is pretty much the closest to the real Spidey we've got now, no?

[DebkoX]

Avengings fun and little.
Enjoy whatever you choose.

[mac01]

I'm more Superior, but i did like the Avenging with the X-men and loved when Spock punched Wolverine made me laugh.
I do like avenging but depends on the other caracter.

[BarryAllen5K]

If Avenging, Daredevil and FF were the only comics I was allowed to read every month... I'd live.