Revisit CBR's Top 100 Comics of 2012

[Ottmeister X]

Why is Saga ranked so high? Sure, the setting is cool, but the dialogue is so awful, I had to stop reading.

No, that's Garth Ennis crap.

I like Saga but I agree with most it's too high on the list. It's definitely not the same quality as Y.

[Hulk_Is]

I've never heard of half of the comics on this list and I really don't think I would want to.............

You're a poster after my own heart.

[Markisan]

Why is Saga ranked so high? Sure, the setting is cool, but the dialogue is so awful, I had to stop reading.

Hype. It is a very good book, but to be honest, it doesn't seem like much has happened in it. Other series are way more deserving.

But aside from that, how does Hellboy in Hell make the cut at 68 when only the mediocre #1 was released in 2012? I love Hellboy but that choice makes no sense. Especially when there are other excellent, recently-launched series with more issues logged last year. If one issue is all it takes to make the cut, then how is Thor: God of Thunder not on here? There were three phenomenal issues of that series in 2012. Or how about any of the Marvel NOW books for that matter. Obviously lists like this are subjective, but I don't get the rationale for ranking one issue of a series in a Top 100.

[cactusmaac]

No Transformers: More Than Meets The Eye? For shame.

Co-sign. Easily my favourite run of 2012.

[FanboyStranger]

Yes, that must be it. People can't be getting something from it that you're not, they're just warped by feminism.

Finally, we have uncovered Dave Sim's sock puppet account.