Trial of Tony Stark: Attempted Murder

[marvell2100]

Has anyone pointed out that Stark has sentenced Jean Grey to death for doing this? Even if you don't consider the Phoenix a life form, Jean Grey is. He should at least be tried for her death.

Along with Magneto, the rest of the X-Men and Shi'ar that tried to kill her.

[PlanetaryDevastation]

jean wasn't a ghost, she was living in the white hot room and protecting the universe. you would know that if you were familiar with anything x-men related from the past decade or so.

I am aware of everything X-men related from Grant Morrison's onward. The ghost thing is a joke.

Second if she don't have a body she is a basically a ghost.

Check yourself.

[Home made ectoplasm]

It was repeatedly stated by X Books Editorial that Jean wasn't dead, she was in the White Hot Room assembling her fragments.

[AcesX1X]

she has a body, it is inside an egg.

[PlanetaryDevastation]

I'm not stating this didn't happen, but could you tell me what book? I don't remember and would like to find it or see if I have it.

There is no book. Jean, since her death by Magneto's whatever (Xorn), been living in the White Hot Room with a bunch of PF folks. Since Tony tried to kill the PF he would be considered as nearly killing her since the PF supports the White Hot Room. Not so sure about that since it supposedly located in the Charka Crown. But whatever.

[PlanetaryDevastation]

It was repeatedly stated by X Books Editorial that Jean wasn't dead, she was in the White Hot Room assembling her fragments.

That makes her a ghost or "energy being" reassembling a body. There really is no difference. Energy being and ghost can be swap in and out depending on the cultural view of a ghost.

[Home made ectoplasm]

That makes her a ghost or "energy being" reassembling a body. There really is no difference. Energy being and ghost can be swap in and out depending on the cultural view of a ghost.

I see where you are coming from but I would posit that ghosts are more intrinsically spooky

[PlanetaryDevastation]

I see where you are coming from but I would posit that ghosts are more intrinsically spooky

Depends on the story I think. Agree to disagree?

[Aguja]

How terrifying it must have been for Jean when Stark caused the White Hot Room to fold in on itself and crush her? :( It's too much.

[Home made ectoplasm]

Depends on the story I think. Agree to disagree?

Sure! It's not as concrete as disagreement, I totally see where you are coming from, and I've found your point of view interesting.

[hysang]

Ah, that's better.

And chastising someone for not knowing X-Men continuity is funny, considering how convoluted and badly written it is. It makes Bendis' mangling of Avengers history read like classic literature.

[AcesX1X]

happy to educate, hysang. jean was a good woman, she deserved better than this.

[Daniel Mengsk]

Then who's prosecuting him.

We the readers. And a bunch of MU 616 Galactic beings or something.

[E. Wilson]

We the readers.

Speak for yourself. If he wasn't a recovering alcoholic, I'd be buying the guy a brew.

[AcesX1X]

Speak for yourself. If he wasn't a recovering alcoholic, I'd be buying the guy a brew.

but he's back on the sauce..