I am a big fan of Geoff Johns' writing. He is my favorite writer at DC right now. I'm not going to say his writing is particularly deep, challenging, complex, what-have-you...but I find it extremely satisfying and presented well to the reader. I think his comics are really fun to read, and since "having fun" is a major aspect of entertainment, I love Geoff Johns' work.
So with that said, I am obviously anticipating this series. Johns has described it as a mix of JSA and Suicide Squad, which sounds great -- strong character dynamics, lots of tension and intrigue. I think the team roster is very interesting, which each character seemingly having some kind of motive or secrets to deal with. I really like how Johns has written Steve Trevor over in Justice League, I'm interested to see how a terrorist like Baz evolves into America's Green Lantern representative, I'm a Catwoman fan, I'm looking forward to the introduction of Stargirl, and I expect Johns to make some major strides in salvaging Green Arrow and Hawkman. Johns always goes out of his way with characters perceived as "lame," so I also expect him to do wonders on Vibe. The recent backup with Trevor and Arrow seemed to foreshadow a Secret Society of Supervillains type group, and with Cheetah and Black Manta already established as prisoners, I'm looking forward to a classic villain team in the making.
David Finch is kind of a wild card. I think his visual sense is right for this book: the initial promo image with the team standing in front of the flag was perfect, the right amount of gritty and iconic. But Finch still struggles with storytelling, facial expressions, body language, and all that jazz, and his work is often too dark. His work on team books is quite lacking IMO, as in a team environment, aforementioned stuff like body language and facial expressions are key in conversation scenes to visually establish characterization. I hope Finch can strike the right balance between the book looking cool, but presenting some satisfying storytelling.
Saga, Chew, Umbral, Deadly Class, The Private Eye
She-Hulk, Loki: Agent of Asgard, The Punisher, All-New X-Factor
, like morrison and even fraction, who often take their work a little to serious and are almost pretentious, are hit and miss for me. But Johns does none of that and in the end if you can have a mix of story and entertainment thats the best. As for the Finch art, What they have shown us looks great, love the martian manhunter, but as fpr consitency in the story I agree with you, but hopefully he can pull it off...
As a reader, I don't really have those needs. I like to be beaten up, challenged, and abused by fiction. I don't need to be gently masturbated through a 12 issue mini-series.
That is why I do not enjoy Johns anymore.
Will give this book a chance. I've been very on the fence, but with my hopes that this will be Johns's return to JSA style writing (which I enjoy), some of the characters I like, and the Matt Kindt back-up, I'll give it a shot.
I've been disappointed with Johns's JL, so this better be...better.
I'm getting it mostly for the team. I like the sort of oddball teams and I've always loved Hawkman and Green Arrow. Simon Baz should be pretty interesting too.
Kind of wish that Firestorm was included in the JLA setup. Would have been a nice shout out to old continuity with Firestorm in the League. Plus, kind of wanted someone to salvage Firestorm which had such a good premise only to fall apart due to execution and changing writers.
I am Apocalypse! Look upon the future and tremble!
I am as far beyond Mutants as they are beyond you. I am eternal.
Evil? I am not malevolent, I simply am!
I hope that the Martian Manhunter back up feature tells us more about his history and gives him a "Martian Manhunter family." There are enough characters in J'Onn's past, as well as new ones in the DCnU, that would work well as supporting characters in his stories.
I can't wait for this book! I feel like it'll be 10x better than his current Justice League book. This one just feels like more of something he should be writing.
Then again we are seeing a couple characters who we really have not seena lot of so I guess it levels itself out!