Page 3 of 4 FirstFirst 1234 LastLast
Results 31 to 45 of 59
  1. #31
    I caught you red-handed Wild_Child's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    1,082

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by dancj View Post
    Wow - What a refreshing thread! I never understood the love the book gets.

    They story was okay and I certainly don't regret reading it, but it's nothing more than that. The writing is not as good as Ex Machina, Runaways or Pride of Baghdad.

    The art is just incredibly drab. There's no character to it and every woman has the same build (I'd probably say they same about the men, but there's only one man). Maybe with a more interesting artist the story would've grabbed me more.
    That's what I was complaining about when I read the book months ago.Most of the females have the same body type.

  2. #32

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Desaad View Post
    It's not that Y is some groundbreaking piece of work.

    It's that it's a smart, characterful, well crafted story with an interesting premise and one that makes every issue hit you across the face with some wonderful development or cliffhanger. The quality of Y is understated, it's not blowing anyone out of the water with it's insight, it's just hugely relatable and incredibly human.

    It's a perfect book to sell people on comics who don't read comics; it's a long form television show in comic form.
    Couldn't have said it better myself. I tried. :(

    Y isn't a great masterpiece, but it's a ride I seriously enjoyed while it lasted. The tv series comparison is spot on.

  3. #33
    Elder Member Libaax's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    10,636

    Default

    I thought Y The Last Man was good but overrated into greatness because it was just such neat idea and not many series with the kind of future Yorick lived in. I rate the characters but the series could have been much better storytelling as overall story. I forget pretty fast how it even ended.

    I think BKV works like EX Machina and Runaways is better. Y The Last Man just gets hype for being in at the end of an era when there was many quality Vertigo, years after mid 90s greatness of Vertigo. Vertigo name can make sometimes some series better than they are. Like every HBO tv shows is The Wire or Rome or Sopranos just because of the channel acclaim rep.

    Im a big fan of BKV and look forward and expect alot from Saga.
    Pull List:
    The Walking Dead,Fatale,Near Death,Storm Dogs,Happy,BPRD,XO-Manowar
    American Vampire,Animal Man,Swamp Thing
    Daredevil, Winter Soldier,Indestructible Hulk

  4. #34
    We have become death Deviates's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2012
    Posts
    1,930

    Default

    It has a good hook, expertly written characters and an ability to keep you intrigued once hooked. I found it a compulsive read and for me, any book that achieves that is going to break in to my top rated list.
    All opinions are not equal. Some are a very great deal more robust, sophisticated and well supported in logic and argument than others.
    Douglas Adams

  5. #35

    Default

    I love me some Y, but I do agree that Ex Machina is more of a page turner/thriller. The political aspects of it are engrossing. This is what got me into reading the news and checking out what's going on in congress etc. But Y. The idea is wonderful, the power of women, the will of one man trying to find his true love, the twist on the genre, the characters that are just so likable. It's a character piece at heart and it's very beautiful.

    I originally read it for the apocalypse and the twist and stayed for the characters. The explanation didn't sway my love at all. Y is a character masterpiece. It had a few slip ups, ANY series does, but overall, it's a wonderful story. THAT'S why it's a highly praised series. My favorite series of all time (At least until I begin to read Sandman. :P Gonna start with the omnibus.)

  6. #36

    Default

    question: how many printings has the deluxe hc's had?

  7. #37

    Default

    I loved reading this book but top 5 seems a bit of a stretch. I mean the ending really did move me emotionally, maybe if it affected others in a similar way that may give precedence for having it so high on the list. Spoiler Alert: When Yorick's Capuchin Ampersand dies I was crying uncontrollably. But I felt less affected when Agent 355 is killed after she and Yorick confess their mutual love for each other.

    All-in-all I love the ending and think its definitely worth owning. Did it say anywhere how the list was determined?
    "It is wrong to assume that art needs the spectator in order to be. The film runs on without any eyes. The spectator cannot exist without it. It ensures his existence." -- James Douglas Morrison

  8. #38

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Ood Friend View Post
    Did it say anywhere how the list was determined?
    Anyone could vote with their top 10 runs. I know I did.
    BB

  9. #39

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Mac! View Post
    The tissue covered with flies scene in the link above is so terrible. Why would you use that to sample a series? It's like their preview for Starman.
    LOL oh my god
    X-Poster of the Month: July 2013
    The Best There Is At What I Do

  10. #40
    Junior Member 400yrs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    345

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by InformationGeek View Post
    And there is my problem. As well written as these characters are, I recongize that and see why others like them, but I just don't feel overly attached to them. I think without that attachment, this comic doesn't have that same meaning or impact to me as it would for other readers. I'm personally more interested in discovering the cause that wiped out almost every male on the planet and why the main character is immuned, which is why I'm reading the comic in the first place.
    I started reading Y as it came out and then dropped it in the teens because I wasn't getting attached to the characters either. After it was completed, I tried it again. It's more of an adventure story than a character story, but there are some very strong character bits that got me involved and attached. By the end, I was attached to Yorick, 355 and even Ampersand. The last issue is phenomenal as well. Many complained about it, but I thought it was perfect.

    It's definitely one of my favorites and something I'll re-read every few years.

    Ex Machina, I enjoyed into the 40s, I think. It was always a very liberal book (since it's about a liberal politician), but the pushiness got to be too much for me.
    Pull List Saga, Invincible, Walking Dead, Chew, Peter Panzerfaust, Superior Spidey, Animal Man, Aquaman, Harbinger, X-O Manowar

  11. #41
    I caught you red-handed Wild_Child's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    1,082

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Wild_Child View Post
    That's what I was complaining about when I read the book months ago.Most of the females have the same body type.
    Most of the female have the same body types except for those nerdy chicks that helped Yorick.

  12. #42
    Senior Member Deep_Sleeper's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    4,553

    Default

    I did try two trades and it wasn't clicking with me. Maybe I should give it another try from the begining? Sometimes things don't click with me from the get-go. I also could not get into Ex Machina, either.

    I thought BKV's Runaways & Pride of Baghdad were amazing and I am really loving Saga, thus far.
    Olivier Coipel - The best damned artist on the planet!

    Shout out to Kev Walker! You're doing a hell of a job!

    Find & follow me on Twitter & Instagram. Check out arfguy

  13. #43

    Default

    I also quit just before the end of the second trade. I've heard good stuff but... it just seemed a little meh. I didn't care too much about the characters. I agree with the poster about likening it to how ever HBO show is the Wire or the Sopranos.

  14. #44
    Lawn-mowing Enthusiast EuphemismForSex's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    A lawn.
    Posts
    3,491

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Billy Batson View Post
    I find the "character" point silly. There's plenty of (Vertigo) series that have better, more memorable and as flawed characters than Y.
    You make it seem like people with the same qualities are the same people...
    Bad news everyone...

  15. #45

    Default

    While I really liked Y (and so did the people I lent the trades too) I wouldn't exactly put it near the top of my best ever list either. Definitely above average, perhaps great and just shy of amazing. I found myself getting attached to the characters and since it's sort of a post apocalyptic setting, that setting always draws me in.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •