Uncanny Avengers #2 Spoilers: No More Mutants v2

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Yes, but the thing is, both Cyclops' X-Men and Wolverine's X-Men (or the Uncanny Avengers) say they are fighting for Xavier's dream even though one side is clearly more in line with what Xavier advocated and the other side is not. And I know die-hard Cyclops fans may not like to hear this, but attempting to achieve peaceful co-existence through force and saying mutants are entitled because they are an "elite species" was not something Xavier advocated.

You do know Xavier wrote the book on child soldiers and used to brainwash mobs, right? Admittedly, he never went on about mutants being an elite species *publicly*, but he was all for his students/soldiers going out in the world to help out.

Current Wolverine basically has the building and the tag line right.

[Filthy Mutie]

Why are you even on this board?

I think he's banned from the Avengers board.

That makes sense.

[AcesX1X]

welcome to the x-forums! hope u survive the x-perience!

[stillanerd]

You do know Xavier wrote the book on child soldiers and used to brainwash mobs, right? Admittedly, he never went on about mutants being an elite species *publicly*, but he was all for his students/soldiers going out in the world to help out.

Current Wolverine basically has the building and the tag line right.

Oh, Charles Xavier was certainly not a saint, I agree with you there. But the thing the X-Men comics tried to get across was that Xavier felt that mutants needed to learn proper control of their powers so they wouldn't be a danger to themselves and to others, and that the X-Men were not so much soldiers as they were protectors just like any other group of superheroes--particularly from other mutants like Magneto who looked down upon humanity. And he also believed in idea that educating the mind was just as important, if not more so, than educating them in proper use of their powers and self-defense techniques. That's what at least Wolverine is trying to emulate with his Jean Grey school. To use an example from classical antiquity, Wolverine's X-Men are the Athenians and Cyclops' X-Men are the Spartans.

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Wolverine doesn't want the kids to get involved period. Chuck didn't have issues with the kids getting involved while there was still work to be done. Emphasis on the latter.

Nobody would have a problem if Wolverine had pulled his Schism drama fit at a better time. Nothing wrong with the intent. Heck, it's pretty much Cyclops' endgame, as per AvX. It's the godawful timing and pack mentality that are utterly baffling.

[kmeyers]

Random question...How did Cyclops get out of jail? Alex visits him there in this issue of Uncanny Avengers, but in All New X-Men, he's running around recruiting new mutants...

[Froggy]

Magneto and Magik broke him out in avx consequences

[kmeyers]

Magneto and Magik broke him out in avx consequences

Thanks, that's what I figured, just didn't read that issue or know which one it happened in.

[Kaiolino]

Wolverine doesn't want the kids to get involved period. Chuck didn't have issues with the kids getting involved while there was still work to be done. Emphasis on the latter.

Nobody would have a problem if Wolverine had pulled his Schism drama fit at a better time. Nothing wrong with the intent. Heck, it's pretty much Cyclops' endgame, as per AvX. It's the godawful timing and pack mentality that are utterly baffling.

Pack mentality? He doesn't even believe in his own community.

[Psyknight]

It was good. Nothing spectacular, but good.

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Pack mentality? He doesn't even believe in his own community.

The choice of word was intentional. Wolverine went emo/crazy over slaying his pack. Now he believes in protecting another incarnation of pack, aka the JGI staff and students.

Remender pretty much nailed it.

[Optic Rage]

Let me ask you a simple question: did Cyclops espouse the rhetoric of mutant superiority or ANYTHING along the same lines from the scans I did post prior to Utopia? If the answer is no, then what caused him to changed his mind?

lol i'm not sure how many ways i can tell you that i don't care what you think about Cyclops. Now, where are the scans showing that Utopia encouraged Mutant superiority over humans?

Are you even reading what he's posting? Cyclops took it upon himself to shape the world how he thought it should be, and your saying he doesn't see himself as morally superior?

Are you reading what i'm posting?

I ♥ u so much stillanerd. You keep fightin' the good fight!

lmao.

I think he's banned from the Avengers board.

This is amazing. I hope he doesn't get banned from here for a little while yet.

[thirdfalcon]

Are you reading what i'm posting?

Yes you are attacking a very specific part of his overall point, and demanding evidence that you know would be a pain in the ass to get and wouldn't change anything if he does get because you'll just say it doesn't prove anything whatever it is. Maybe he was off a bit on how far Cyclops had gone up until AVX, but he had certainly been going in that direction since he started X-force.

You could try to be productive about it, but you'd rather be antagonistic because stillanerd is threatening your personal version Cyclops's character arc that isn't supported by the books or anyone at Marvel.

[Optic Rage]

Yes you are attacking a very specific part of his overall point, and demanding evidence that you know would be a pain in the ass to get and wouldn't change anything if he does get because you'll just say it doesn't prove anything whatever it is. Maybe he was off a bit on how far Cyclops had gone up until AVX, but he had certainly been going in that direction since he started X-force.

You could try to be productive about it, but you'd rather be antagonistic because stillanerd is threatening your personal version Cyclops's character arc that isn't supported by the books or anyone at Marvel.

Nice try but no. I don't care about Stillanerd's opinions on Cyclops(lol why would i?). I caught a part of his post that was blatant BS and i'm just waiting for him to try and back it up.

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Yes you are attacking a very specific part of his overall point, and demanding evidence that you know would be a pain in the ass to get

That would be because there isn't any.