Dean & Sam join Fringe while Pete & Olivia go Supernatural

[Red Winter]

Imagine Sam & Dean Winchester from Supernatural join the Fringe division while Peter & Olivia Bishop from Fringe Investigate the Supernatural,who will come out in one piece?

[big_adventure]

Imagine Sam & Dean Winchester from Supernatural join the Fringe division while Peter & Olivia Bishop from Fringe Investigate the Supernatural,who will come out in one piece?

Important question:

Which versions of which characters? Powered Olivia? Powered Peter? Powered Sam? Powered Dean? Can Sam and Dean call Cas and/or Death?

Peter is pretty intrinsic to the core Fringe plot - without him, there wouldn't BE a Fringe plot, or Fringe events, or anything else. Walter also wouldn't be involved, and without those two, no Fringe cases, if they happened at all, would ever get solved.

Now, if you wanted to replace the entire continuity with the characters - Peter and Olivia are Winchesters, know Bobby, etc., Sam is Walter's kid and Dean is a cortexaphan baby, I'd give the advantage to the smarter ones. Sam's clever, but Peter's a low-end comic-book genius.

[Drax1981]

Olivia is pretty screwed up and her powers relied on her being able to process emotion. An alcoholic repressive like Dean on cortexiphan would have lightbulbs exploding all over the place, bouncing between universes like a tennis ball in an earthquake.

[Stigma Rex]

Important question:

Which versions of which characters? Powered Olivia? Powered Peter? Powered Sam? Powered Dean? Can Sam and Dean call Cas and/or Death?

Peter is pretty intrinsic to the core Fringe plot - without him, there wouldn't BE a Fringe plot, or Fringe events, or anything else. Walter also wouldn't be involved, and without those two, no Fringe cases, if they happened at all, would ever get solved.

Now, if you wanted to replace the entire continuity with the characters - Peter and Olivia are Winchesters, know Bobby, etc., Sam is Walter's kid and Dean is a cortexaphan baby, I'd give the advantage to the smarter ones. Sam's clever, but Peter's a low-end comic-book genius.

Not nessisarly it could be like at the start of last season where Peter was lost in time, from when he used the Machine, and the Fringe time line is one where he didn't exist. Walter still worked for them,(though he wasn't nearly as happy), and Lincoln seemed more involved with their team.

As for the scenario, I'm not sure as I've only seen a single episode of Supernatural.

[big_adventure]

Not nessisarly it could be like at the start of last season where Peter was lost in time, from when he used the Machine, and the Fringe time line is one where he didn't exist. Walter still worked for them,(though he wasn't nearly as happy), and Lincoln seemed more involved with their team.

As for the scenario, I'm not sure as I've only seen a single episode of Supernatural.

The problem with that analysis is that a) that was a pretty different series, effectively and b) Peter DID still exist, and was still the cause of everything, the Invaders had just tried to wipe him out. They failed to do so, and we wound up back where we were supposed to be, more or less.

[Stigma Rex]

The problem with that analysis is that a) that was a pretty different series, effectively and b) Peter DID still exist, and was still the cause of everything, the Invaders had just tried to wipe him out. They failed to do so, and we wound up back where we were supposed to be, more or less.

Your right mostly but they still did several episodes without Peter, so its not like the universe would fall apart instantly without him. If this was a dimenson swap, then the Winchesters should be work on some cases in Fringe, while Peter and Olivia fight demons and what ever else the Winchesters do.

[dupersuper]

Sam is Walter's kid and Dean is a cortexaphan baby

There goes Emma...

[Kuro]

Is it just me, or have they almost completely abandoned or retconned the alternate universe, as well as the cortexaphan angle in the new season? You'd think they'd mention it, at least once..

[big_adventure]

Is it just me, or have they almost completely abandoned or retconned the alternate universe, as well as the cortexaphan angle in the new season? You'd think they'd mention it, at least once..

They mentioned, in passing, something about the cortexaphan trials in one of the first couple of episodes, but they dropped it just as quickly.

[Drax1981]

Was it someone other than Olivia or Peter who brought it up? They're working on a different set of memories than everyone else.

[Surtur]

Is it just me, or have they almost completely abandoned or retconned the alternate universe, as well as the cortexaphan angle in the new season? You'd think they'd mention it, at least once..

Personally I really haven't enjoyed a majority of the new season. It has started to pick up again once Peter spoilers:

got the Observer powers

end of spoilers, but overall I've been disappointed. It is a shame this being the final season, though I suppose there is still time to fix it.

As for the alternate universe..well, it pretty much has been abandoned. It makes sense since they had to sever all ties with it and I think I recall Walter mentioning at least once this season he was afraid of becoming like the Walternate, but I could be wrong.

[big_adventure]

Was it someone other than Olivia or Peter who brought it up? They're working on a different set of memories than everyone else.

It was Olivia. I think that I deleted the episode and don't really care enough to redownload it, but there it was.

[big_adventure]

You're a good person, I don't care what Siriel and Sharp say about you.*

[Surtur]

You kinda might want to put spoiler tags around your first paragraph. Someone who was waiting to watch the episodes could be kinda put out by the bomb you dropped there.

Ah yeah my bad..I changed it..but my edit most likely won't effect the quote in your post so you should probably edit it.

[Kuro]

Personally I really haven't enjoyed a majority of the new season. It has started to pick up again once Peter spoilers:

got the Observer powers

end of spoilers, but overall I've been disappointed. It is a shame this being the final season, though I suppose there is still time to fix it.

As for the alternate universe..well, it pretty much has been abandoned. It makes sense since they had to sever all ties with it and I think I recall Walter mentioning at least once this season he was afraid of becoming like the Walternate, but I could be wrong.

The new season is... questionable. I mean, I'm enjoying it obviously. Fringe has always had a very special place in my heart, but it seems they're completely forgetting what happened in the previous seasons. I understand this takes place years after season 4 ended, but there are some elements that make no sense.

Why is Walter always hinging between having his a chunk of his brain and added in again? This was already dealt with in a previous season, I believe. The operation was a success. Apparently, he wanted to have it removed again, some time between then and now? And at the beginning, it was added again? Huh?

Since when was William Bell back in the picture? Dude disappeared in season 4, IIRC. Apparently, he came back between season 4 and 5 and he conducted experiences, which apparently made him god-like with Walter. Funny. You'd think that opening a door to another universe and almost having it and his own destroyed would have taught Walter not to trifle with reality?

It seems like they scrapped almost the entire series and basically made it so that it went from season 1 to now.

Besides that though, I'm enjoying season 5 a lot. I thought it sucked that

spoilers:

Olivia and Peter's daughter died

end of spoilers

but I am sure there will be some time manipulation thing to fix that.. otherwise the writers would be REAL dicks for making this happen.