Advance Review: ALL-NEW X-MEN #1

[AcesX1X]

Beast is not the heart and soul, but he is the moral compass of the X-Men. Beast Knows Best!

beast is about to get his ass handed to him by the guardians of the galaxy for his questionable "morals"

[Peter F.]

They also gave X-Men Legacy #1 a 3/10.

Seriously? That preview alone looks better than the entirety of the last run

[Optic Rage]

Seriously? That preview alone looks better than the entirety of the last run

Too high concept for them i guess.

[Kaiolino]

It was pretty obvious the reviewer didn't understand what was happening in the comic. If it had Morrison's name on the cover, the reviewer would be raving about how hard his mind was fucked by the high concept of it all.

[Perfection/Emma 2]

Cannot wait until tomorrow.

[.A²]

It was pretty obvious the reviewer didn't understand what was happening in the comic. If it had Morrison's name on the cover, the reviewer would be raving about how hard his mind was fucked by the high concept of it all.

Yeah I have to admit, this was the same exact impression I was left with after reading that review.

[Bushido Brown]

Eh, can't say I'm a fan of Newsarama's reviews. Hopefully I end up enjoying this tomorrow.

[J/O/J/O]

Wait thet really gave Legacy such a low score?F##k that review section.

[mystery_saw]

I was\am a little worried that they gave Legacy such a low rating. It's one of the books I'm most excited for. I'll just made my own decision when it's released tomorrow.

[jsg2295]

"If the Phoenix Force can get people up in arms, why isn't a mutant abusing time travel not cause for alarm?"
About the only part of the review I agree with.

[graffiX]

It was pretty obvious the reviewer didn't understand what was happening in the comic. If it had Morrison's name on the cover, the reviewer would be raving about how hard his mind was fucked by the high concept of it all.

LMAO so true.

[Fluffyblade]

I think reviews on comics are pretty much useless since people's taste vary so much. Unless you know someone has similar tastes to you then a review isn't likely to o you any good.

[Omega Alpha]

I think reviews on comics are pretty much useless since people's taste vary so much. Unless you know someone has similar tastes to you then a review isn't likely to o you any good.

The point of any review isn't give opinions you agree with, but rather present a thoughtful and unbiased (or as unbiased as possible) view of the issue, analyzing it's strengths and virtues, without spoiling things too much. That review doesn't strike me as thoughtful at all.

And of course a big problem with comic reviews is that it isn't that big of a business and it's hard to see negative reviews in the one's that are clearly more pushed by editorial, since if Marvel and/or DC decides to screw with them, they're out of work.

[LooneyKoala]

Really looking forward to this!

But... CYCLOPS IS NOT A VILLAIN!!!

No Wolverine in it eh? That's good! I love the guy, but he's in too many places and can suffer from bad characterisation A LOT! Was at his best in the early 80s.

[LooneyKoala]

Bad review for Legacy? Off to find and read that review...

I'm still undecided on it. But figured I might as well check it out! Might enjoy reading a bit of Legion.

EDIT: Despite them constantly talking about it in a negative light, that review makes me like the sound of it even more! Haha!