REVIEW: Uncanny X-Force, #33

[CBR News]

"Uncanny X-Force" #33 continues Rick Remender and Phil Noto's "Final Execution" with a gruesome showdown between Nightcrawler and Blob.


Full review here.

[HotWire]

AOA kurt looks psycho

[Regino]

Ugh, a Kelly review. We need Doug or Ryan on this.

[MarvelMaster616]

I think it's a fair review. I would give it a slightly higher score, but I think the criticism in the review was fair. This book was a bit unbalanced in that it spent so much time on Daken and Wolverine that the other ongoing battles seemed a bit glossed over. It's still awesome in that it has all the gloriously violent elements that make Uncanny X-Force so great. But it just wasn't as cohesive as it usually is. I still have high hopes for the next issue. Either way, I'll be sad to see Rick Remender's run on this series end.

[Seresecros]

It's not the presence of Phil Noto, it's the absence of Dean White

[stinkbrown]

Ugh, a Kelly review. We need Doug or Ryan on this.

Thanks for the vote of confidence, Regino. However, I pretty well agree with Kelly on this one. It was a good issue, and 3 stars is good. I thought it felt a little thin, though I dug the chat between father and son. UXF is one of my favourite books right now, and of all time, but this issue was 3.5 at tops. I'd need to honestly sit down and reread if I was going to give a firm number but I think Kelly nailed it pretty well here.

And you know that isn't CBR crony lip service. I'd launch Kelly into the moon if Remender asked for it ;)

[Nicoclaws]

It's not the presence of Phil Noto, it's the absence of Dean White

That's what is bothering me with this arc !