Steven Spielberg (Friend of Lucas, has often come close to directing a SW)
George Lucas again
David Lynch (Almost directed ROTJ)
David Filoni (director of Clone Wars movie and series)
Christopher Nolan (The Dark Knight Trilogy)
Joss Whedon (Serenity, Avengers, various TV series)
J. J Abrams (Star Trek, Super 8, various TV series)
Frank Darabont (Almost directed TPM)
Kathleen Kennedy (Basically is co-chair of Lucasfilm)
Gendy Tartovsky (The original Clone Wars micro series, various TV series and Hotel Transylvania)
Brad Bird (Incredibles, Mission Impossible IV)
Francis Ford Copolla (Godfather trilogy & friend of Lucas)
Peter Jackson (Lord of the Rings trilogy)
Guillermo del Toro (Pan's Labyrynth, Hellboy)
So obviously it's not the use of CGI in itself that you have an issue with, but something else. A lack of craftsmanship perhaps. Or indeed because a lot of the vehicle designs look absurd or funny. Personally, I think the prequel trilogy ranks with The Mummy 2 and 3 as one of the worst uses of CGI in cinematic history. But it seems to me that people her are saying that there is no such thing as good CGI and that models are inherently superior, no matter what.
'The marquis. Well, you know, to be honest, he seems a little bit dodgy to me.'
'Mm,' she agreed. 'He's a little bit dodgy in the same way that rats are a little bit covered in fur."
Okay, this is from a UK tabloid so take it with a grain of salt. But remember how there were some of us who speculated on whether or not Disney would have Darth Vader return? Well...
http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/...be-resurrectedFollowing news that Disney has bought the rights to the lucrative sci-fi franchise and plans to make at least three more movies, industry insiders say the evil Vader will grace the big screen again.
“He’s an integral part of the franchise. Replacing him is virtually impossible,” explains a film mole.
“The plan is for him to return and play a significant role in the new films.”
Last edited by stillanerd; 11-13-2012 at 01:04 PM.
and this...industry insiders...
says it all. Any time an article claims to have a source inside the production, I take it with a whole oceans worth of salt. Industry insiders doesn't mean they are inside Disney or Lucasfilm and a film mole doesn't mean they are a mole at Disney or Lucasfilm....explains a film mole...
This article amounts to me to nothing more than "let's post a wild but largely hoped for theory of what the new films might contain and hope that it is proven right so we can look like we actually had the information".
Tis a matter of opinion.Well, it was. They're very fake looking, the hair doesn't look real at all; they're like little cartoons in a live-action movie.
The bottom line is that the film had the best of both.Yeah, that doesn't change anything I said.
The budget has to do with where the money is spent. Lucas felt it was more practical to put the money on CGI suits, than creating a dozen different suits for one extra to wear. Especially given that said suits are difficult to move in and see out of. Lucas was also going to have a large number of troopers moving at once, rather than doing it as he did with the OT.I know you're trying to make a point, but I'm not sure what the hell it is. What does each movie being budgeted at $125 have to do with anything? Those movie I listed all cost less than that, as well as what each of the prequels actually came in at.
That's why the end result is one guy, Bode Taylor, wearing a green and/or a blue screen suit. This one guy was then used to create the singular movements for the Jango Fett clones, so that they all line up a certain way. The same way that your body movements are different from your family members, much less your friends, as opposed to a clone. Taylor was then replicated through the use of computers, just like LOTR, allowing for multiple troopers on screen at once.The way Attack of the Clones is shot, there wouldn't have been a big need to have that many people in real clone trooper armor; they would likely only have needed like eight guys in suits. They wouldn't have needed all those people running around in the background where detail doesn't matter as much be real people, they just needed them for shots where they're doing stuff like talking to Samuel L. Jackson, shooting laser guns in dust, riding in those clone trooper ships...just things where they're more in the foreground.
The armor all varied. Different colors, different equipment, different shapes.Each peice of armor was virtually the same in the new movies too. The clone troopers pretty much just look like Stormtroopers with speed fins on their heads.
The OT was just as much a demo for ILM. And all the models and matte paintings were just as obvious.Yeah, it's readily apparent what he did, the prequel movies are less like movies and more like demo reels for ILM. A lot of people could also tell they were CGI, it's blatantly obvious they're CGI.
Why? That's what is done. A person does motion capture and then the effects team creates the look of whatever it is in post production. That was what was done with the Clonetroopers.This doesn't even make sense with what we're talking about. I was talking about having people in real costumes, not blue suits. You wouldn't need to CGI out people that already look like what you're going to CGI in...that would be crazy.
There were models used in the PT as well. The difference is that in the OT, we're seeing ships that have been around the block. In the PT, we're seeing ships that are in a time of peace. And then we see wartime ships in ROTS. But in basic terms, it's still the same.Originally Posted by Alex
The oceans of Kamino are CGI because of "The Perfect Storm" where it was used to create the hurricane scenes on the ocean. ILM did the work on that and applied it to AOTC. It's a bit difficult to obtain actual tidal waves of that magnitude in real life, which is why CGI had to be used in both films. In terms of Coruscant, that is precisely why Lucas dropped it from ROTJ. Because he couldn't do it the way that he wanted to, back in 1982 and waited until he could. He didn't want to rely on models alone like with "Blade Runner" and "Superman". As to the aliens, many couldn't be done with just puppets alone and stop motion would have been just as noticeable and time consuming.The new stuff looked pretty, but there will always be an issue with cgi. Attack of The Clones, i think when they went to the planet where they were making the clones, you had cgi buildings with cgi aliens and cgi walls with cgi floors with cgi skys and cgi water, and then an actor standing there. You can't possibly make that look real, it's a fake overload.
No more than you can with the older, practical effects.I don't think there is anything that can be done to make that not look fake.
Jedi Starfighters were built on set. Slave I was the same model, only slightly tweaked, from TESB. In ROTJ, the Falcon wasn't on set. Only the cockpit was used. The rest of the shots in the hangar were a matte painting. Lucas did have partial external models made of the Falcon, an X-Wing, a Y-Wing, a B-Wing, an A-Wing and the Imperial shuttle since he couldn't do what he could in the PT. This cut back costs for building and tearing down the ships from the on location and on set scenes. When necessary, actual props were created for the actors to use.It looks more fake because it actually is more fake. Super shiny super sleek spaceships don't exsist, so of course they aren't going to look real.
But an X wing? People have probably built life sized xwings in real life.
That would only work after ROTJ, if the film has a younger cast and it takes place immediately after. Otherwise, the Alliance would inform everyone that Vader killed Sidious and both were dead. Besides, there is no theory. There is wild speculation, the opposition of theory.Originally Posted by Vibranium
Last edited by Mat001; 11-13-2012 at 02:28 PM.
Didn't they have full-size podracers for part of TPM? Not in motion but the scene at the beginning where the racers are all being announced and moved onto the track. In fact I think the very first look at TPM's model shop included a pod.
Although apparentally the filming for that scene suffered because of a sandstorm which damaged the set.