
Originally Posted by
Scott Harris
Okay, so with the initial reboot arc finished, I want to say a few words about Steve Trevor. Overall, I don't have a problem with returning the status quo to Wonder Woman's 1940's roots, because frankly it was when she was at her best and other than the I-Ching era, the character has basically been floundering ever since. So I get it and for the most part I applaud it.
However, I do have a problem with Steve Trevor. The problem? The way they have the dynamic between Diana and Steve set up is exactly, 100%, to the letter a mirror image of the relationship between Superman and Lois Lane. Steve is in love with Wonder Woman, and not only doesn't realize Diana is Wonder Woman but completely ignore and overlooks her. Meanwhile, she pines away for him as Diana, all the time thinking "if only Steve knew that I am actually the woman he loves!"
Maybe this was interesting in 1942 when it was still fresh, but decades upon decades of Mort Weisinger beating this motif into the ground and beyond in the pages of Action, Superman and Lois Lane had rendered it boring and stale long before this reboot happened in 1979. There is simply nothing you can do with this. Further, as one writer pointed out in the lettercolumn, it doesn't make any sense because Wonder Woman is Diana's true identity. "Diana Prince" is just a front she set up in order to get access to government information; it's just a pose, a shell. There's nothing there. Clark Kent at least seems to have a life and personaity of his own; he's the real character while Superman is just the guy he turns into when trouble appears. But Diana Prince is literally nobody. So why all the coy subterfuge around Steve with her identity?
The answer is obvious and should be obvious to Diana as well in the comic: She should tell Steve -- and Etta -- that she is really Wonder Woman. It puts her and Steve on equal footing so their relationship., such as it is, can actually develop instead of being stunted by this pointless masquerade. It also removes logistical problems that make aspects of her stories unbelievable. As a military officer working in the Pentagon, randomly disappearing for hours on end is just not possible without being immediately discovered and reprimanded. Yet somehow she manages to do this all the time. If she had Steve and Etta in on the game, they could help cover for her, especially as Steve is her ranking officer and boss. And telling Etta also makes sense, because Diana needs a confidant in man's world just as much as Etta needs a friend. Right now that friendship is a one-way street as long as Diana hides her true self.
Granted, I am writing from the point of view of having read an additional 32 years of secret identity stuff, and in today's modern comics, the secret identity is usually treated very differently than it was then. But even in 1980 the secret identity stuff had long since played itself out as a real source of interesting stories. I hope Wein and Conway realize this and ditch this aspect of their plots in favor of having Diana reveal her identity to Steve (something she had done prior to his death in #179). It may be the only way to allow him to become an interesting character instead of just a boring Lois Lane clone.
Bookmarks