I will always love pre-Flashpoint JSA, but I have to be honest, the last decade really was a struggle for me -- especially the last incarnation. I wanted to see the JSA young and active again and not a bunch of wannabe's. My ideal situation for the JSA would have been E-2 being the original pre-Crisis earth and set in the 40s. It's not what I got, but something is better than nothing.
Now that Earth-2 is here, I'm in love and I'm glad it is what it is. Robinson has been careful and respectful with the characters. Nicola's art is breathtaking. This is an amazing title and an example of a reboot done right.