General critical consensus mean nothing to me as do Nolanites.
This quote says it best:
So your statement that the two film series are "clearly... equally good" is based on what, exactly?
Regardless of your feelings for any of these films-- Nolan's or Burton's--there's no grounds for civilized discussion if your entire mode of reasoning is based on "Nolanites" being wrong, and general critical consensus meaning "nothing."
Express your opinions, but be aware that that's all they are: opinions.