
Originally Posted by
Plawsky
This was easily the best issue of the new series so far. It's finally starting to feel like the old USM, which remains one of my favorite superhero books of all time. The pacing is better, but still not perfect. However, Bendis (after a year) finally does what I've been waiting for and adds some drama to the book. Teen drama is what made me love Ultimate Spider-man, and I've been really missing that. I'm in my twenties and I'm not ashamed to admit that.
What was great:
-Judge's frustration with his roommates
-Batroc was a lot of fun, he's like the new Shocker
-The art. David Marquez is still doing a great job.
-Miles has an Ultimate Power poster.
-The talk between Miles and his dad.
-The twist appearance of May and Gwen
-May giving Miles Peter's web shooters (presumably)
What was not so great:
-The Batroc fight was way too long.
-The Bendis-speak was still rough in places ("Can we meet? We should meet."), though not as bad as it's been before.
-It seems that Aaron is for sure dead. Too bad if it's true, because he had a lot of promise (though he could come back extremely easily).
-Cap's stupid costume
As much of an improvement as this has been, Bendis still has room to go to match the old days for me. If the book didn't crawl so much, I would be a much bigger fan. The Batroc fight was a great, fun moment, but it had no need to take up nearly half the issue. It took up 9 of this issue's 20 story pages. The great fight in USM #8, debut of the Shocker, lasted only 4 pages out of 22, and it accomplished the same thing. Bendis is telling a solid story here, but he's wasting space. This book is becoming great again, but it could be even better with just a few adjustments.
As a side note, this almost certainly puts Spider-men AFTER Divided We Fall. This is clearly the first meeting between Miles, May and Gwen, and it seems likely that they'll meet again in #4 or 5 of Spider-men. However, if he's getting the web shooters here, why wasn't he using them in Spider-men? Yes, you can easily say that he just decided not to use them, but his reaction to Peter's web shooters was more surprised than it should be if he already has some? Or maybe he gets the shooters here, but doesn't use them for a while. But knowing now that Miles meets the girls here, I suppose that's why Spider-men #4 was pushed back from the original bi-weekly schedule.
It also seems a little strange that Cap would take the time out of his day for something so minor while there's much bigger problems to be had. At least Bendis acknowledged how minor this Miles problem is, but that doesn't really make Cap's decision any smarter.
Overall: 8.5/10
Bookmarks