Which would you prefer?

[1505627]

1. A Live Action anime adaptation

2. A CGI anime adaptation

you can assume the following about these

1. they are theatrical releases
2. they are ,at very worst, average.

[Mr. Holmes]

CGI. Even a lot of these live action adaptations use so much CGI special effects, combine that with the stylized trappings, they become live action cartoons.

[Dark Soul # 7]

Depends on the anime.