Rank the 4 Super-titles

[DrewHLMW]

1. Action Comics / Supergirl -both are awesome
2. Superboy is good and he's finally starting to establish a life for hismelf in the latest issue.
3. Superman - while it is the weakest of teh 4 i have really enjoyed it overall and look forward to teh new team.

Super books have been the strongest for me as its the only group that I still buy every title from.

[paulski]

Action Comics

Supergirl

Superboy

Superman

Swap the order of the first two, and we agree.

[super1man]

Most Everyone seem to agree that Action is #1 and Supergirl #2 though there is a sizable gap there. Superman and Superboy is so-so though hopefully both will become better soon.

[Sacred Knight]

Actually I'm one who contends the gap is not that sizeable. I think Action is the better title, but not by a whole lot. Morrison is definitely weaving the more complex and epic tale by a long shot, but insofar as just general quality in writing and art, Supergirl's right there.

[super1man]

Actually I'm one who contends the gap is not that sizeable. I think Action is the better title, but not by a whole lot. Morrison is definitely weaving the more complex and epic tale by a long shot, but insofar as just general quality in writing and art, Supergirl's right there.

I did say most all not all. And yes Supergirl is good. Superboy is becoming better. I just hope Scott can make Superman a good read and then we get a Steel book and then a 3rd, a 4th, a 4th, a 6th .... Superman books.

[Sacred Knight]

I know, I wasn't trying to insinuate you were trying to speak for everyone, just was throwing my hat in there.

[Hammer!]

Ok I just finished the first seven issues of Superboy (now at 22/52)! Have to say I was disappointed. It wasn't Hawk and Dove or Green Arrow bad, but it was pretty damn average. Some pretty good ideas were thrown out, but in general the series was pretty repetitive with Superboy defeating vastly inferior opponents with ease every issue. Really seemed like a character that no one would like if he didn't have the "Super" attached to his title. I liked the supporting cast and tie in to TT, but I didn't really like the character all too much. Hopefully the series gets better as the character finds his place in the world. On the plus side, I liked his Tron outfit instead of a blue/red knockoff, and RB Silva really improved every issue. Gets a 5/10 from me.

[ForeverYoung8]

1. Smallville
2. Action
3. Superman
4. Superboy

I haven't read Supergirl outside of the first 2 issues, so I can't comment. Dropped Superboy after 6.

[stephens2177]

Ok I just finished the first seven issues of Superboy (now at 22/52)! Have to say I was disappointed. It wasn't Hawk and Dove or Green Arrow bad, but it was pretty damn average. Some pretty good ideas were thrown out, but in general the series was pretty repetitive with Superboy defeating vastly inferior opponents with ease every issue. Really seemed like a character that no one would like if he didn't have the "Super" attached to his title. I liked the supporting cast and tie in to TT, but I didn't really like the character all too much. Hopefully the series gets better as the character finds his place in the world. On the plus side, I liked his Tron outfit instead of a blue/red knockoff, and RB Silva really improved every issue. Gets a 5/10 from me.

Well why did you stop reading at seven? Read the last two issues,it is way better than the middle issues you read.

[Talisman]

Supergirl
Action
Superboy
Superman--I was a fan, but seriously this book needs a shot in the arm.

[John Ossie]

Supergirl
Action
Superman
Superboy

Note that my order of preference from Action to Superboy is based solely on what my friend David has been saying about them lol I only read Supergirl out of the four.

[bluebeetle73]

Action (reading it)
Superman (reading it)
Supergirl (thinking about dropping it)
Superboy (dropped it)

[Flash Gordon]

Action Comics
Supergirl
Superman
lots of other stuff
Superboy

[Chunt]

1. Action Comics - Started off great. Sliding into obscurity and WTFness. Slowly rising back up again.
2. Supergirl - She's more interesting by the fact she can still only speak Kryptonian.
3. Superman - TERRIBLE from the get go and continues to fall over its own crapness.
4. Superboy - Never liked the character. I don't like having more than Superman, Supergirl i thinks okay and makes sense... but there doesn't need to be a massive Super family. It's what makes Superman unique...

[stephens2177]

1. Action Comics - Started off great. Sliding into obscurity and WTFness. Slowly rising back up again.
2. Supergirl - She's more interesting by the fact she can still only speak Kryptonian.
3. Superman - TERRIBLE from the get go and continues to fall over its own crapness.
4. Superboy - Never liked the character. I don't like having more than Superman, Supergirl i thinks okay and makes sense... but there doesn't need to be a massive Super family. It's what makes Superman unique...

By definition kara takes away from kals uniqueness as last kryptonian,and superboy is a human created clone to be a living weapon,probably against the alien he gets some of his dna from.he doesnt make superman any less unique in anyway,and because his powers are totally different,supermans powers would still be one of a kind.if you dont like a big superman family,superboy is the perfect way to have another S shield wearer without having multlple kryptonians running around.

Oh and he is badass,sorry you haters cant handle his TK powered partial human dna,the abomination of the house of EL indeed.sorry for mucking up the pristine kryptonian gene pool of excellence.

Jk....mostly lol.