As for the Mr. Majestic thing...armor works for him because he's an alien warrior. Kal is not. He's an alien who happens to be the defender of earth, but he is a product of two worlds. He was born on Krypton, but at heart he isn't an alien, nor is he quite human either. He's the best of both. The costume to me ALWAYS was a representation of both his Kryptonian and human heritage. It should be based on the dress of his planet of origin (and depending on the era, made from Kryptonian materials) and put together by his earth parents as a gift for their son. When he's Superman and wearing that suit, he's wearing his dual heritage for all to see, equally proud of both. Having him just simply find it on Brainiac's ship in a glass case to me feels too cheap and takes away from the uniqueness of the suit, in my opinion. That's why I almost wish that he was still wearing the t-shirt and jeans 5 years later. Yeah it looks a bit silly, but at least it sticks to the paradigm of his Superman persona being a product of both his nature and nurture. The Cape and insignia is of Krypton, the rest is of his Kansas, midwestern USA earthly roots.
Damn that is some beautiful art. I do have a minor gripe with the coloring though. The glistening of the armor is just a tad overplayed for my taste.
Currently Reading: The Authority, Bone
Comics Of Days Past - Reading the greats of yesteryear
I can't speak for DC/Warner...I don't work there so I don't know what's actually going on (I assume you can't and don't as well) . All I know is what I see and read. And what I see and have read are valid points as to why he looks the way he looks and dresses how he dresses. All of it makes sense for this incarnation of Superman (you really can't say otherwise on that).
I have always seen it as Superman putting on his "kilt" and by that I mean dress and garb from his homeland. Just because it's not an amalgamation of two worlds does not mean he doesn't hold both in high regard. (in character) Grant has called Clark's cape his "security blanket" and "best friend" since he was young. He didn't even understand what it was but he knew it was the only thing he had left of his homeland so he loved it. Now he has the chance to get in touch with this place in a whole new way (the ship and armor) so he's gonna jump at the chance. This however is not to say that earth is just and after thought now, no. He grew up here and became the man he is because of here. He honers earth by being the same "fight for the little guy" man he has always been.
He even goes as far as to assure us of his unchanged status in Action comics #8 where he says that he's still the same guy even with the suit. But he also gives props to the suit because it saved his life during that fight in space. Both the blanket and suit are almost like his mother and father still protecting him even now. This is ALL in character and it makes sense and feels natural.
As for Majestic....I'm pretty sure in my last post I said that it was in character for him to have it because of who he was AKA a warrior even though he doesn't need it. Nowhere in my post did I say that Superman had his because he was a warrior (I give you why he has it above) Both may not NEED it but both have completely valid personal in character (relevant to this Superman) reasons for having them.....That is what I wanted to get across with the Majestic parallel nothing more.
Also the fact is that we got best of both worlds as you even pointed out in your post. He started T-shirt and boots from the farm then went on to alien armor and the best part is....the whole world saw him in both so he is known for both in some way shape or form. He even goes as far as to go back and forth with the to looks for either convenience sake or to put people at ease.
From an interview with Grant we Actually know that the reason he actually had the white T and not the blue T in issue 4 was because he wanted to look more patriotic with how things were going in his life at the moment.
Also the suit is not always a representation of his two worlds. Most of the time it's one or the other. Examples..Superman the movie: Krypton, Lois and Clark: Earth. 1st incarnation of Superman: Earth. The list goes on. It's never actually been a staple for it to be from both worlds. A lot of the time it's over looked or just glossed over.
This is the one time that I feel he has a strong almost (slightly) dependent relationship with what he has on. The blanket was how Superman knew he was safe as a kid even if not much could hurt him. This new wrinkle in his character is a very quirky, interesting, and humanizing in a very odd way so he still seems different than us even while we're humanizing him (story of his life)....well at lest that what I think.
But mainly my point is that it makes very good sense for THIS Superman which is (like all of his incarnations) an off shot of the concept as a whole.
Sorry to bore you lol
I would love to continue with the debate, but perhaps later. Family Reunion picnic tomorrow, gotta get things together and get to bed soon. By the way, you would all be invited...but my family might object to a few hundred strangers in Superman and DC t-shirts raiding the potato salad and fried chicken and burgers, so I hope you all understand.
Again, Superlad thanks. You won't change my mind ( and I won't change yours) but at least we can all agree...Superman is awesome, Always was, always is and always will be!
That looks quite good, Kenneth's art will definitely be a selling point for the book more than the writing.
Sure doesn't look wimpy to me. And I don't get why Superman needs to look like an Alex Ross-drawn 50 year old or else he looks like a boy.
Last edited by Sacred Knight; 06-17-2012 at 12:36 AM.
That Superman Cover is so fricking cool
I am Hawkboy...Master of the Skies!!!!!!
... The Master Of Puppets has spoken.
Goodbye León (november 16th, 1993 - june 12th, 2009). You were, are and always will be the best friend I ever had. I will always love you and never forget you. And please, please forgive me.
Thank you for teaching me about love, patience and caring. Rest in Peace, my friend. I hope that wherever it is you are now, you can run and play as much as you want.
Last edited by manofsteel1979; 06-17-2012 at 06:33 AM.
Anyway, his Superman doesn't look wimpy to me. I think one of the "complainers" had a nice comparaison by saying he looks a bit "elfic". But I don't mean that in a bad way. There 's some grace in that picture, in the way he's hovering as if it wasn't a big deal, and in his general traits. Yet, he doesn't look weak or effeminate. I think that balance between the two is very similar to the way elves are portrayed in Lord of the Rings for instance.
"I'm going to paraphrase Nietzsche, when you judge a work, the work judges you."