My wife knows I've been wanting to frame and hang some floppies in my office at work. Apparently she spent a few afternoons at my LCS, getting all available sales staff along with a few helpful customers to find issues she knew I wanted and identifying other good looking covers. She was so excited that she gave them to me last night.
After realizing Chew #1 was over $200 she settled on the following:
Batman v1 #628
Batman v1 #660
Superman v2 #75 (regular not polybagged)
Superman v2 # 204 (Superman: For Tomorrow - pt. 1)
Superman v2 # 205 (Superman: For Tomorrow - pt. 2)
All-Star Superman #1
Green Lantern ('05) #1 (Alex Ross variant cover)
Lantern is my favorite as it was the most unexpected. Also, it's worth mentioning, if you are in, or around Columbia, MD and need comics; the guys at Comics To Astonish were fantastic to my wife and even the customers were helping. Customer service like that should be acknowledged.
Hope you fellow Dads get equally thoughtful gifts.