Rank The Robins! 2012 Edition!

[batmanjones]

Dick Grayson (whom I wish had been Robin at the beginning of the relaunch)
Helena Wayne (because, duh, she's Helena Wayne)
Carrie (the original alt-Robin)
Damien (because props to Morrison bringing back that Son of the Demon story and because Damien's fun)
Jason Todd (pre-relaunch - I don't care about him now)
Tim Drake (yawn)
Stephanie Brown (yawn)

[Chainshada]

Tim
Dick
Damian
Steph (much better as Batgirl)
Jason (Like him as Red Hood, hate as Robin)

[Samy]

This is a lot of incarnations, but I'll give it a shot. For reference, this is ranked by who I enjoy reading about.

1. Dick Grayson (Nightwing)
2. Dick Grayson (Batman)
3. Dick Grayson (Robin)
4. Stephanie Brown (Batgirl)
^^^ YAY

5. Stephanie Brown (Robin)
6. Damien Wayne (Robin)
7. Jason Todd (Robin)
^^^ Okay

8. Tim Drake (Robin)
9. Tim Drake (Red Robin Reboot)
^^^ Meh

10. Tim Drake (Red Robin Preboot)
11. Stephanie Brown (Spoiler)
12. Jason Todd (Red Hood Preboot)
^^^ Slight nose-wrinkle

13. Carrie Kelly (Robin)
14. Jason Todd (Red Hood Reboot)
^^^ HATE

[StDumas]

I can't get on board with splitting a single character into multiple choices.

(1) Dick
(2) Damian
(3) Jason
(4) Tim

I also can't get on board with counting anyone who was ever drawn in a Robin costume, so that's Stephanie Brown and Helena Wayne out. I wouldn't rank Carrie Kelly, either, because Frank Miller's Batman is hopefully "elseworlds" by now.

[osoito]

I can't get on board with splitting a single character into multiple choices.

(1) Dick
(2) Damian
(3) Jason
(4) Tim

I also can't get on board with counting anyone who was ever drawn in a Robin costume, so that's Stephanie Brown and Helena Wayne out. I wouldn't rank Carrie Kelly, either, because Frank Miller's Batman is hopefully "elseworlds" by now.

I agree word for word, from start to finish.

[Spiderboy12]

Frank Miller's Batman, outside of Year 1, has always been "Elseworlds". That said, I see where you're coming from. Otherwise, perhaps we ought to count Bruce Wayne, Jr., "Robin II" from Batman #131, 135, and 145, along with other alternate (imaginary, Elseworlds) Robins.

[Jay Y]

1. Dick
2. Tim
3. J-Bird
4. Damian

That is all.

[samurai_rob]

Frank Miller's Batman, outside of Year 1, has always been "Elseworlds". That said, I see where you're coming from. Otherwise, perhaps we ought to count Bruce Wayne, Jr., "Robin II" from Batman #131, 135, and 145, along with other alternate (imaginary, Elseworlds) Robins.

Well, that's kinda my point in starting this thread. If you want to take the time to list them, I'm all for it. I wanted people to list as many or as few Robins as they want and I love reading the posts where folks take the time to explain their choices. I'm amazed just reading this, at how many Robins that I had forgotten about myself. So, as stated before, everyone feel free to go as deep or as shallow into the Robin pool as you want! : )