Which Emma do you prefer?

[amhixson]

Time for round 2.

Which version of Emma do you prefer? Why?

And, what year did you start reading X-Men?

[MrHalfawake]

Gen X was the only time I could remotely stand Emma

[RoguishGurl]

I want to vote for Morrison Emma, but that option includes the current Emma. I feel like they aren't the same.

[Jake V]

Morrison Emma and post-morrison Emma are basically two separate characters.

[Optic Rage]

Morrison Emma obviously.

It's fair to say she's had her ups and downs since then. I'm thankful for her current decent characterization.

[passer-by]

The original Emma was one of the more interesting X-men characters/villains. Considering her background, her haughty and disdainful attitude to other people was finely coupled with her lack of morals and compassion. I miss her.

I started in July 1986 with the X-Men in Japan for Logan's wedding (yes, Logan - not Howlett).

[fortyseven]

The original Emma was one of the more interesting X-men characters/villains. Considering her background, her haughty and disdainful attitude to other people was finely coupled with her lack of morals and compassion. I miss her.

I started in July 1986 with the X-Men in Japan for Logan's wedding (yes, Logan - not Howlett).

Are you the owner of motherofpearl?

[passer-by]

No, why? Do you find my position so unique that it can't be shared by more people? :)

[Faded]

I want to vote for Morrison Emma, but that option includes the current Emma. I feel like they aren't the same.

Agreed, this poll confused me.

Morrison/Milligan BY FAR. I would've liked her more in Gen X if she didn't look so damn frumpy.

[Home made ectoplasm]

Claremont Emma and Morrison Emma

[fortyseven]

No, why? Do you find my position so unique that it can't be shared by more people? :)

The "Yes Logan NOT Howlett" bit was a tad unnecessary. I don't see anyone calling Wolverine "Howlett" in this thread.


Milligan Emma is one of my favorites versions of Emma for (on-topic-ness sake).

[Washout]

The "Yes Logan NOT Howlette" bit was a tad unnecessary.


Milligan Emma is one of my favorites versions of Emma for on-topic-ness sake.

Milligan just got Emma. I miss him.

[passer-by]

The "Yes Logan NOT Howlett" bit was a tad unnecessary. I don't see anyone calling Wolverine "Howlett" in this thread.

Point taken. The changes in Claremont's Emma reminded me of the overdose in the making a background for Logan which in CC's opinion was unnecessary and I fully agree with that. But you're right, I shouldn't have mentioned it here.

For on-topicness sake, I find the current Emma too bland and PC compared to the original.

[Quinnhop]

Morrison Emma and post-morrison Emma are basically two separate characters.

Thank you. What a terrible poll.

[coveredinbees]

Gen X and Claremont