rank the new 52 batman titles

[loki lauyfeyson]

could either be a list of all titles in order of preference, or could just be a grouping of really good, ok, and bad or something like that. i know not everyone reads every title so omiting any titles you dont read is fine. and were only judging based on the titles since the new 52 nothing before that.

[batGRRRl4ever]

I only read Batgirl & Birds Of Prey. I've decided I'm not a fan of the current writer of BOP and most definitely am not a fan of oncoming artist Travel Foreman, so this book in terms of rank has fallen like a stone and issue #8 will be my last until a creative team change-up.

Batgirl is my #1. It had a shaky start in moments with both writing and art here and there, but as of issue #8 this is a very solid title and I look forward to each one.

[The Greatest Hero]

Of the ones I read, I'd say Batman is #1. Maybe.

[El Sombrero]

I feel like I just did this, but...

Batman - the best by far. Best writing, best art, best storyline, best everything.
Batwoman - the JH issues are really superb. The non-JH issues have been pretty poor. Needs to get back on track real soon.
Birds of Prey - very well done title but fails to keep my interest on a regular basis.
Red Hood - awesome art, very cool style, I don't care for the characters though.
Catwoman - March's art is fantastic, I like the characterization, but the storylines and supporting characters are extremely weak.
Dark Knight - a total crap book but at least it's entertaining
Detective - I'm starting to enjoy it in a "so bad it's good" way
Batman and Robin - I don't like Tomasi's writing or the hyperviolence
Batwing - just bores me, at least it's creative / original though
Nightwing - also bores me, less creative. Needs more style.
Batgirl - horrible creative direction and execution. I have no idea what they were thinking taking the title in this direction.

[Dr. Hurt]

Batwoman
All-Star Western
Birds of Prey
Batwing
Batman
Red Hood
Batman and Robin
Nightwing
TDK
Catwoman
Detective
Batgirl

[Cavemold]

Out of the books I have read
1.Batman
2. Batwing
3. Nightwing
4. Batman and robin
5. Batwoman
6. Red hood and the outlaws
7. The dark knight .

[Box]

1. Batman
2. Batman And Robin
3. Batwoman
4. Detective Comics
5. The Dark Knight
6. Batgirl

[Reginleif]

Best to Worst From What I Own:
1. Birds of Prey
2. Huntress

[a13506]

1-Batman, 2-Batwoman, 3-Batman & Robin, 4-Nightwing, 5-Birds of Prey, 6-Batwing, 7-Dark Knight, 8-Catwoman, 9-Batgirl, 10-Red Hood, 11-Detective.

[Godlike13]

From what i read, or have read.

-Im quite enjoying these
1. Batman
2. Nightwing
3. BoP
4. Batgirl
-Marginally enjoying these
5. Batman And Robin
6. Batwoman
-Meh
7. Detective Comics
8. Catwoman
-
9. Red Hood and The Outlaws

[Captain Jim]

Batman
Batman & Robin
Nightwing
Batgirl
Detective
Birds of Prey
Batwoman
Dark Knight

Dropped:
Batwing
Catwoman
Red Hood

[Mr. Holmes]

Good:

1. Red Hood and Outlaws (that's right, come at me).
2. Batwoman
3. Batman
4. Birds of Prey

Decent:

5. Batwing

Mediocre
6. Catwoman
7. Nightwing

Crap:

8. Batman and Robin
9. Dark Knight
10. Detective Comics
11. Batgirl

[Red_10]

Really Good
Batman

Good
Batwoman
Batwing

Surprisingly Good
Red Hood

Still Reading for now
Catwoman

Dropped, just kind of "meh"
Nightwing

Dropped, actively bad
Batgirl
Dark Knight
Detective Comics

Haven't read
Birds
Batman and Robin

[Xarcon]

I'm currently only geting Birds of Prey, Batman, and Batwing, but I'll be getting Batman, Incorporated next month and The Dark Knight in June when Hurwitz takes over.

In Order:

Excellent
Birds of Prey
Batman

Good
Batwing

Average
Batman & Robin
Catwoman

Poor
Nightwing
Batwoman

Terrible
Detective Comics
Batgirl

Haven't Read
Batman: The Dark Knight
Red Hood & the Outlaws

[MajorHoy]

Favorite: Batman

Also read (in alphabetical order):
* Batgirl
* Batman and Robin
* Batwoman
* Nightwing
but all of these are ones I may consider dropping, especially after Night of Owls
(and I'm aware Batwoman doesn't have a tie-in)

Had dropped but started buying again:
* Detective Comics (but not sure if I'll still go back to dropping it after Night of Owls)

Had dropped but may try again:
* Batman: The Dark Knight (plan to buy Night of Owls tie-in; may stick around for new writer)

Dropped and not considering picking up again (unless there's a change in writers):
* Catwoman

Not reading (but might consider in future):
* All-Star Western
* Birds of Prey
* Batwing

Haven't read / not considering:
* Red Hood and the Outlaws

Haven't decided upon yet:
* Batman Incorporated

Still miss:
* All-New Batman: The Brave and the Bold