Did Geoff Johns Steal Batman Earth-1 from Frank Miller and Darren Aronofsky?

[vampiric_cannibal]

It's almost a direct adaptation because nearly every thing other than that element made it into the movie.

So just everything except what makes the character likable. Gotta love Hollywood.

[thwhtGuardian]

So just everything except what makes the character likable. Gotta love Hollywood.

He was still plenty likable. Rami's movies, at least the first two, were pretty faithful adaptations, I really don't see how that could be argued otherwise.

[Russell]

How do you guys know the plot for Batman Earth One?

BTW Spider-Man does crack wise in the Raimi movies, not much, but he does. And the movies still captured Peter perfectly.

[Mr. Holmes]

How do you guys know the plot for Batman Earth One?

BTW Spider-Man does crack wise in the Raimi movies, not much, but he does. And the movies still captured Peter perfectly.

It was hardly perfectly. Peter never moves on from being this semi-repressed kid. It's why I'm glad they're rebooting the series.

[dancj]

I don't see how a Spider-Man who doesn't crack wise could be considered "almost a direct adaptation".

If you'd have complained about the organic web shooters or the changes to the villains you'd have a point, but there were plenty of wisecracks. IMO they got his personality spot on.

[Choppa]

It's almost a direct adaptation because nearly every thing other than that element made it into the movie.

Changing the bridge scene was a pretty big departute from the comics.