It's too early to tell. So much hinges on how this first arc plays out. How some of these things are resolved will determine what the vote will be. The writing has been good, but there is a lot of potential for the whole thing to fall flat - much more potential than the first arc of Action or Superman, for example.
Until we know all the circumstances around Batman being caught in a maze for a week (as one example) we won't know for sure if this is really good or if will collapse into the ludicrous. Until we understand why Talon appears to totally outclass him as a strategist and as a fighter, I feel I can't judge the quality of the title.
But Snyder certainly does have me coming back for more.