This is a cop-out. You are basically accussing me of something that you are actually currently in the process of doing. I came up with a scenario and you are doggedly trying to poke holes in it which is fine. What I find hypocritical is you doing so but then refusing to subject yourself to the same scrutiny. And no I would not simply dismiss it. If I disagreed with it but thought it had some merit I would say so just like I did during our previous discussions when I acknowledged the validity your arguments against my opinion on Obito knowing about Edo Tensei. So there is documented evidence in this thread of me accepting the validity of someone's arguments even if I disagree with it. I haven't done so in this debate because you haven't given me anything to consider beyond saying that peace would have happened because a guy who butchered his family said maybe there was another way. I want an example of exactly what an agreement looks like because a negotiation typically involves both sides giving and taking. So what in your mind are the concessions that could be made to appease both sides? Again, perfectly fine if you don't want to but accussing me of something when there is evidence in our previous discussion that accussation is false and when you are engaged in the very thing you accuse me of is not debating in good faith.
And Danzo is not a well-intentioned extremist. The manga made it pretty clear he resented Sarutobi for acting when he couldn't which resulted in Sarutobi become Hokage. Danzo's problem is he thinks that his own personal desire for power and his desire to protect Konoha are one in the same. Did you forge this well intentioned man murdered Kosuke to prevent Naruto returning during the Pain invasion and then had his Root goons stanby while Pain attacked because he wanted the murder and mayhem to result in people losing faith in Tsunade? Like I said, sure he wanted to protect Konoha but he was not well-intentioned because well-intentioned would mean putting Konoha above his own personal goals and he couldn't do that because he thought they were one in the same.
For the record this is an example of where I find you are doing what you accuse me of because the logic here makes no sense. Danzo is one of the most senior advisers in Konoha along with the two old farts. To pretend it is impossible for him to request and be granted a meeting with Sarutobi is just silly. This would be like the head of the CIA calling up Obama and saying Mr. President I have a matter of national security to discuss urgently and then you asking me why would Obama meet with the head of the CIA? Um because a leader routinely meets with his key advisers. As for Itachi, it is Danzo who cultivated the relationship with Itachi and got him to spy on the Uchiha for Konoha. He is more a direct subordinate of Danzo than he is of Sarutobi. Furthermore, since he is the one supplying the information on the Uchiha if Danzo says he has a matter of national security to discuss involving the Uchiha, inviting the guy who is currently the main source of information on them makes perfect since. There is simply no logical reason to say Danzo cannot get a meeting with Sarutobi and Itachi. And read my posts again, I never said Root could kill Itachi. I said they would be present at the meeting or be seen by other people far away from the Uchiha to provide an ALIBI. When Obito murders the Uchiha, if Danzo is meeting with Sarutobi and Itachi and his Root goons conspicuously present, then there is no real way for the murders to be pinned on him or his goons.
Obito wants to rewrite the world. A united Konoha with all the Uchiha makes it much more difficult. It's basic divided and conquer. Rather than face them all together, he helped Itachi eliminate a group of people that would make it more difficult for him to achieve his plan. In the absence of Itachi going along with the plan, it is still advisable for Obito to kill them to prevent a United Konoha posing more trouble in the future such as the Ninja Alliance in the last chapter including ALL OF THE UCHIHA. And no Obito does not want to kill Itachi. If he could get away with murdering the Uchiha without Itachi finding out then he would. Hence why he would use Danzo to keep Itachi occuppied. Clearly if Itachi sided with Konoha though then it is a problem for Obito because again he doesn't want to see Itachi a part of the Ninja Alliance.
What secrets do you think Obito is not aware of when he has access to the knowledge of Madara? We don't know how the massacre went down. You are assuming that Obito had to exert himself to the fullest when it is far more likely he let Itachi do most of the work because well Itachi was there and Obito likes to play things close to the vest. Given what I have seen of him in his recent fights and given without Itachi, I am pretty sure he could manipulate some of the members of Akatsuki to help, I see no reason to assume a kid screams.
Having said that, I acknowledge it is a possibility (notice how I don't totally shoot it down as impossible) but simply think it is unlikely given Obito's power levels. I mean hell what is preventing him from using the Zetsu to help him do the deed as I am pretty sure they were around then? Look, you don't have to agree but to try and pretend like it is impossible for one of the best ninja's in the ninja world with access to all of Madara's knowlege and Akatsuki to boot to murder the Uchiha quietly is just you being stubborn when we know Itachi and Obito did it and there is no indication in the story that Obito had to exert himself tremendously to do so.



Reply With Quote

Bookmarks