I haven't had this feeling since playing Diablo for the first time. Brutal cynicism, outright fear of what's coming next, worrying that my skills, my level, my powers aren't good enough and not knowing when to run from a fight or not.
Dark Souls. I making a thread for it because I think it lived up to the hype of Demons Soul's. Plus, I want to hear how other people are doing, if they are playing it.