Im like both Elixir and Wither. Im don't know why we can't like them both. Shame that Wither died.
Wither had a lot of potential to be his generation's Rogue. He also could have deftly picked up the goth/emo slot that was left by Chamber from Generation X and fit into the Vampire Diaries, Twilight, etc tortured romantic brooding dark male archetype.
I was happy that he fell in with Selene, especially given Selene's history with Kevin's former teacher Danielle Moonstar, but disappointed that he didn't have a longer run as a character.
BUT, I liked some of the characters, like Wind Dancer, Wither, Prodigy, and Elixir. And, I always love Dani!