Should Scarlet Witch join the Xmen?

[MsWhite]

over the years the Xmen have allowed some of their worst enemies onto their team. Mystique, Sabertooth, Magneto, Danger, but Wanda was the one that decimated their numbers.

She is a mutant, and the daughter of Magneto, shouldn't she be kept closer to the Xmen rather than the Avengers?

[Home made ectoplasm]

They've accepted villains, but not perpetrators of genocide.

I get the impression that Marvel is planning on rehabilitating the Scarlet Witch. I really wish they wouldn't. Her character is tainted for all time.

[Greckel]

They were all hesitant and angered when Scott allowed Magneto to join and I am sure Wanda would receive even worse reception. I am sure Scott would be fine with allowing her to live on Utopia, simply because she is a mutant, but as for being allowed a primary role within the X-Men, hell no.

[The Black Guardian]

Sure... right after they let the Trask family and Cameron Hodge join.

[Home made ectoplasm]

Important thread related to this:

Are Quicksilver & Scarlet Witch the biggest dirtbags you've ever seen?

Wanda is like Fred Phelps for the X Men.

[red eyes]

They let Magneto and Frost in so why not her

[Greckel]

I get the impression that Marvel is planning on rehabilitating the Scarlet Witch. I really wish they wouldn't. Her character is tainted for all time.

They should spend 5 issues rehabilitating her up until she saves the entire mutant race and then perishes, but is forever in the hearts of the X-Men for correcting her past deeds. Only then can she be a member of the X-Men, provided that no Marvel writer ever chooses to resurrect her.

[The Black Guardian]

They let Magneto and Frost in so why not her

Because she's more evil than both of them ever were put together.

And a horribly boring character.

[ExodusCloak]

They should mount her head on a wall.

[red eyes]

Because she's more evil than both of them ever were put together.

And a horribly boring character.

It's been hinted in Childrens Crusade that it MAY not have even been her fault,

Also even if she did do it she may not have thought through fully the ramifications

Just because you think she's boring dosen't mean she could'nt join the X-men, their are plenty boring x-men imo

[Home made ectoplasm]

Are Quicksilver & Scarlet Witch the biggest dirtbags you've ever seen?

^^ Just scanning this again, probably one of the best threads on CBR, highly recommended (and due a revive)

[Seresecros]

[ExodusCloak]

Also even if she did do it she may not have thought through fully the ramifications

Endangered Species makes that point moot. Wanda has no regrets.

[Havok83]

No but her brother can

[The_Greatest_Username]

no...Wanda should not join the X-Men, she's an Avenger