Hey today I got this trade for less than 4 dollars!!!! your opinion on it??

[Ciro]

Hey I just got this trade for less than 4 dollars!!!! (otherwise I don't think I would've got it)

http://www.dccomics.com/dcu/graphic_novels/?gn=4848

How about that uh!!

If anyone happens to have it or read all the issues involved I'd like to know your opinions on how good is it, I don't mean the art because skimming through it I can see it's good, so any opinion you formulate exclude your appreciaton of the art from it.

No, I mean the writing, specially Phil Jimenez part, thnx in advance.

[titanfan]

Graduation Day = Arguably the worst Titans story ever written.

Return of Donna Troy = A lot of exposition and back story, but worth it if you're a fan of Donna. The art is gorgeous.

[dancj]

They were both pretty lame. Graduation Day at least was readable and provides some useful background for The Outsiders. The Return of Donna Troy was just a slog from beginning to end.

[mr.brighteyes]

The Donna Troi stuff was lousy and I couldn't make heads or tales out of it. I loved Graduation Day though.