Should I respond to the top comment on the last page or has the troll finally left?
In Kieron Gillen I TrustKGB since 3/10/11
"Um, blah, blah, blah. And, Girl Power. Feminism, d'you know what I mean?"
I've got a continuity question. Remember how Illyana used to have 'beware of the demons' signs on her door? It's understandable how she could have those after Mutant Massacre, but how did she have them up while she was still rooming with Kitty Pryde? Did she just put them up whenever the X Men were away and take them down before Kitty got back?
My old comics are in storage, and I never did own the Uncanny issues between the Dark Phoenix saga and the X Men getting kidnapped by the brood (including, sadly, Uncanny 160). I've reread summaries of all the issues between when Kitty Pryde joined the X Men and then (if their first appearence is any later then my default assumption is that Illyana put them up) on Uncannyxmen.net and couldn't find a single reference to any signs on Kitty's door. It's possible that it's a detail they missed, but they're usually very thourough that way. In New Mutants, Illyana and Magneto stated explicitly that the signs referred to Illyana. I guess Illyana could have used them as well as Kitty, and that Illyana could have added her own sign(s) to Kitty's, but I really don't like those answers very much. My basic problem was what good would those signs do Illyana if her roommate could barge in at any time unnannounced as Illyana seemed to be on guard against sudden entry in New Mutants 44. If the signs were put up by Kitty than I can see how they would do her good even if she had a roommate they did not apply to, but that question still stands for Illyana no matter who put up the signs.
And this just raises other problems. Kitty put up the 'beware of demons sign,' you say. And she kept it up even though she knew her roommate had been kidnapped by demons for seven years. That is hard to believe. Simply based on what I've seen my original assumptions still make the most sense, even if it isn't much. Those signs just seem to be a plot hole.
So having valid complaints about the she-demon's actions makes me a troll. Good to know.
You don't have to respond if you don't want to.
You've been here long enough to know better.2. PROFANITY
Don't use profanity.
Last edited by Peter F.; 07-07-2010 at 05:24 PM.
Going out of your way to deliberately antagonise the regular posters on a thread makes you a troll. Yes.
I don't go to the threads about characters I dislike to rant about them. (Although someone stated that I dislike Pixie, it's not exactly true. I like as much as I like any character, just not like I like Batman or Wolverine Or Magik. She's a little annoying, but not that much. I've even defended her on occasion in other threads. Characters I dislike are Amanda Sefton and the post Inferno replacement New Mutants.) I could, but I don't. I don't know if any of the regular posters here do, or how people who do that are tolerated on those threads, but I know that they are not tolerated here.