Was Mary Jane Pregnant during One More Day?

[Eye in the Sky]

Keep in mind the OP, May finds out from Petes now non-existent daughter.

They sacrificed a life for a life. Not the marriage.

I don't see how that's possible. The daughter hadn't been conceived yet, unless that is why MJ was throwing up in OMD, if the child doesn't exist you can't sacrifice it. If I want to buy an X-Box and I have $300 and then something happens to my car that requires $300, I didn't sacrifice the X-Box to fix my car. If I had an X-Box, then sold it to fix my car, then I would have sacrificed it. You see how that works?

[Lord Foul]

I don't see how that's possible. The daughter hadn't been conceived yet, unless that is why MJ was throwing up in OMD, if the child doesn't exist you can't sacrifice it. If I want to buy an X-Box and I have $300 and then something happens to my car that requires $300, I didn't sacrifice the X-Box to fix my car. If I had an X-Box, then sold it to fix my car, then I would have sacrificed it. You see how that works?

That is why she is throwing up in OMD. Plus we see her in the comic as a little girl.

*Puts Eye's analogy in the paper shredder.*

Not too mention I'm sure given the idea is close to the idea of abortion, meaning we can sit here till the end of time debating it.

[ShaggyB]

That is why she is throwing up in OMD. Plus we see her in the comic as a little girl.

*Puts Eye's analogy in the paper shredder.*

Not too mention I'm sure given the idea is close to the idea of abortion, meaning we can sit here till the end of time debating it.

so you know for a fact that MJ is pregnant in that scene?

link to proof please.

Otherwise you are speculating and your theory is built on said speculations.... Sturdy as a house of cards and all that......

[Eye in the Sky]

That is why she is throwing up in OMD. Plus we see her in the comic as a little girl.

*Puts Eye's analogy in the paper shredder.*

Not too mention I'm sure given the idea is close to the idea of abortion, meaning we can sit here till the end of time debating it.

so you know for a fact that MJ is pregnant in that scene?

link to proof please.

Otherwise you are speculating and your theory is built on said speculations.... Sturdy as a house of cards and all that......

What he said.

[Lord Foul]

Your both of you are mearly avoiding the question by deining the obviousness of the situation in OMD.

The avatar of Joe Q himself was not enough to convince you then I would be wasting my time.

[Eye in the Sky]

Your both of you are mearly avoiding the question by deining the obviousness of the situation in OMD.

The avatar of Joe Q himself was not enough to convince you then I would be wasting my time.

What's the obvious question?

[Lord Foul]

I don't have this irrational hate for Joe Q like you seem to. What's the obvious question? Ask me and I'll answer it. Come off like a prick and I'll tell you where to go get your head run over.

You asked for proof that MJ is pregnant in OMD. Giving the obviousness of it I find putting it in question is mearly a way of deining the point.

[Eye in the Sky]

You asked for proof that MJ is pregnant in OMD. Giving the obviousness of it I find putting it in question is mearly a way of deining the point.

Well you can either believe her answer that she's just upset, that she's sick of the current situation, or that it's morning after sickness, but we didn't see any fucking or hinting of fucking going on, Peter was out in the black suit getting revenge. So I tend to not think it's morning sickness and I believe the answer she gave.

[Karl Cook]

You asked for proof that MJ is pregnant in OMD. Giving the obviousness of it I find putting it in question is mearly a way of deining the point.

I hate OMD (that's fairly well documented...) but I don't know what to make of the panel showing MJ throwing up.
I wasn't sure whether she was being sick because she was pregnant or if she was being sick through the stress brought on by Mephisto's offer.
It was fairly ambiguous in my opinion and I'm not sure whether that's due to clever writing or lazy writing, I really can't decide...

[Jim Thompson]

I hate OMD (that's fairly well documented...) but I don't know what to make of the panel showing MJ throwing up.
I wasn't sure whether she was being sick because she was pregnant or if she was being sick through the stress brought on by Mephisto's offer.
It was fairly ambiguous in my opinion and I'm not sure whether that's due to clever writing or lazy writing, I really can't decide...

Probably depends on if you liked the story or not -- if you liked it, it was clever writing. If not --

[Karl Cook]

Probably depends on if you liked the story or not -- if you liked it, it was clever writing. If not --

Well I loathed the story so lazy writing it is then!

[Eye in the Sky]

Probably depends on if you liked the story or not -- if you liked it, it was clever writing. If not --

It can still be clever writing and still not enjoy the story. Grant Morrison's X-Men is very well written, I'm just not a fair of a lot of his stories there.

[Karl Cook]

It can still be clever writing and still not enjoy the story. Grant Morrison's X-Men is very well written, I'm just not a fair of a lot of his stories there.

Grant Morrison is an exception though. Grant gets to do anything he likes with established characters like X-Men but it'll get ret-conned as soon as he leaves the title.
What's the betting that his Batman run gets wiped out after he leaves? Knowing DC, you won't get very good odds.

[Lord Foul]

Well you can either believe her answer that she's just upset, that she's sick of the current situation, or that it's morning after sickness, but we didn't see any fucking or hinting of fucking going on, Peter was out in the black suit getting revenge. So I tend to not think it's morning sickness and I believe the answer she gave.

If that was all to it I would agree, but then the avatar of Joe Q came along and spelled it out for us before that scene happened.

Parphaised "I'm willing to give up everything."-the red haired girl.

The discussion left nothing to guess really.

[Eye in the Sky]

If that was all to it I would agree, but then the avatar of Joe Q came along and spelled it out for us before that scene happened.

Parphaised "I'm willing to give up everything."-the red haired girl.

The discussion left nothing to guess really.

I don't see how that is definitive proof she was pregnant. So no, it's still left up to a guess as to what was going on with that.