Search:

Hi antiochene, thanks for being so gracious. In return, I'm sorry for jumping to conclusions, and for my snarky phrasing about defending Emma's honor.

I actually concede your point that my...

Thanks, harashkupo! I remember you, actually, from when you disagreed strongly with my Harbinger review rating, but you were polite about it.

I felt pretty defensive, but I respect opposing...

Hi, it's the reviewer here, Jennifer Cheng. celestialbodies is right that had made it (more) clear that Emma was reacting to Jean, that this might not have pissed off CBR forum people as much into...

Thanks for reading my review, harashkupo! Also, thanks for defending my reviews; I am flattered.

I see what you're saying about the lower rating/score of 3.5 stars. There were a lot of great...

Thanks for reading my review, everyone!

Opus, it's not so much that I require or demand specifically a dramatic cliffhanger ending for every issue, as in that the ending itself felt weak in terms...

Glad you liked it too! I completely agree with you that it had touching wrapups without being maudlin, which is tough to pull off.

Hi Brave Sir Robbin (love the username, BTW), thanks for reading my review!

It wasn't uniformly amazing all the way through (which is why I stopped just short of giving 4.5 stars, but I wavered...

Okay, it just goes to show that people get different things out of columns, because I really enjoyed this one and the point was crystal clear to me.

Brett talks about his specific personal...

Thanks for reading my review, everyone!

And erwinrafael, 1derer -- Wow! thanks for the compliments; I blush. And here I thought I was going to get slaughtered in the comments for giving Hawkeye...

Hi everyone, thanks for the comments on my review.

FHIZ, I see that you were annoyed. For the record, my editor at CBR really enjoyed "Batman and Robin Annual" #1 and if another reviewer had...

No worries, BugsySig, it did not come off as personal, just a polite concern about timeliness. I see what you're saying, too, that DC and Marvel have a market advantage, and therefore early vs. late...

Also, BugsySig, I saw your comment on my last Bloodshot review about the review coming out the week after the book was out. While it's true that my job is not to promote Valiant (and BTW, thanks,...

Thanks for the feedback, Captain Craig.

(1) Lovely phrase, "for supremacy of fate."

(2) Thanks for criticizing CBR reviews and reviewers without being abusive, and I definitely understand...

Thanks for the compliment about the review, BugsySig. I agree with you about the last issue being disappointing (although the art was fine) but as you said, this issue really redeems it all.

I...

Hi Shingen,

Another reviewer here. Due to (1) time and (2) reluctance to engage with hostile commenters, I've responded only to posts when I feel I've either made a mistake or the commenter is...

Hi Fred,

I just saw this. Thanks for the kind words and for quoting me (in French)! Best wishes for 2013 and for more great comics!

Thanks, Matt! I like your apt phrase/concept "flash-and-glitter" stage. I agree about being happy to follow "The Hidden Kingdom". Though more shallow than I'd like, tourist trips and pretty lights...

Hey Prisoner 6655321 --

Image is reprinting Bedlam #1 and the second printing will ship with Bedlam #2 next month. With any luck, your shop will get copies of it then and you can check it out...

Hi Hypocee!

My reading for this issue was sloppy and I goofed, even though I liked it a lot. I've only been a reviewer for about 2 months so far and I figure it's bound to happen eventually.
...