Search:

Yeah, I'm in agreement with those who aren't terribly fond of the title right now. Gotta say that I loved Winick's work on the book--I actually thought it was one of the more underrated titles since...

Yeah, that kinda surprises me; I've always considered her one of the better X-females outside of the group's core mainstays(Storm, Rogue, et al). As for least favorite, I'd probably go with Frost as...

Haven't liked Giffen's art since his first tenure on the original series circa the Great Darkness Saga so this doesn't bother me much. Plus, I LOVED Portela's art on the book. The big letdown for...

My sentiments exactly, although if this poll is to be believed--and that's a big if--she's probably the only female that's joined in the last 25 years that's had any lasting impact outside of Jean...

Psylocke. All-time fave X-Man, male or female.

I'd be good with Polaris and definitely with Dazzler. But I doubt Emma will have the time; she'll be too busy swallowing Bendis' Uncanny whole like she did Morrison's, Whedon's, Fraction's and...

Yeah, not sure where people are getting Rogue outranking Storm. I'd say Storm follows a close second behind Cyclops as far as definitive X-Men leaders go but maybe that's just me.

While I would def prefer Polaris or Dazzler--who would be even better, seeing as how that would give us the entire female half of Claremont/Silvestri's Outback roster--over Jubilee, the rest of this...

Yeah, I still appreciate the concept--though it was done much better when Bendis was aping Warren Ellis during his DA run--but it's very hard to get past that art, which is wildly inconsistent and...

Agreed. Still don't like that character, no matter who's writing her.

Glad someone besides me recognizes this; it's been the Scott and Emma Show for the better part of a decade and frankly I'd be totally okay if I never saw Frost in another X-book for the forseeable...

Well, I'm on this big time; love the creative team and LOVE the line-up(thank GOD there's no Emma, though I would've loved to have seen Lorna here). I suspect this will be competing strongly for a...

His name escaped me at the time but yeah that's the guy(I think Val Staples was actually the colorist on that series). Either way, not excited about Mhan's involvement.

Guess I'm in the minority but I really liked Green's work on the book plus I think his style is very similar to Rocafort(though Rocafort I think is in a class by himself). The only previous...

Glad to see they're giving this another shot though I wish someone other than Mhan was drawing it. It's too bad they couldn't get the guy who drew the Image MOTU series a few years back; his artwork...

Not a fan of Bendis at all--though I begrudgingly admit that I'm somewhat enjoying All-New X-Men, with the exception of him getting Frost's dialogue completely wrong--but I'll give this a shot though...

Yep, I was waiting to see when Bendis' very bad habit of making characters sound nothing-at-all-like-they-previously-have was gonna rear its' head; I guess I'm surprised it took til the third issue. ...

I actually never minded Wozniak's Excalibur stuff other than it was a drastic departure from Davis' more clean and straightforward artwork(felt the same way when Erik Larsen followed Steve Lightle on...

Could not agree more. His art is very nice(though contrary to what Alonso alluded to in that interview that first issue cover was abysmal) but I'd hardly call it extraordinary enough to warrant all...

I like this line-up, though I'd sub out No-Girl for Sage or even Polaris. Still, I think Wood/Lopez could make just about any line-up work.

Not sure what's going on with the mullet, but I hate the costume(and not because of Caselli's art; I just don't like it period). Still, the art is gorgeous, def the best this book's seen, and while...

I'll echo you and everyone regarding the art--Larocca is definitely back on point here after trying something "different" in Iron Man for the last few years. Looks as good as his X-treme X-Men and...

Yeah, Davis is in my Top 5 all-time fave artists so I hope this is anything but Wolverine(and totally agree with you on JR JR.; I've NEVER understood the hype on that guy's work but thirtysomething...

Yeah, I think Deodato's been great for awhile now(and dependable), especially his Thunderbolts run with Ellis and everything he's done with Bendis(Dark, New, etc). If I'm not mistaken, he's slotted...

Lol, that was the very first thing that jumped out when I saw that cover. For a character who changed costumes every storyline or, hell, every two or three issues, it is odd that she's still wearing...