Buffy Survivor: Seasons 1 thru 7

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Giles is a washed-up alcoholic who doesn't know when he's not needed anymore! :p


But his alias was 'Reaper', so he can get away with being like that. :p

[Chiasm]

Giles 6
Anya/Anyanka 8-

[tangentman]

Giles 6
Anya/Anyanka 9+

[Chiasm]

Giles fears nothing. Anya fears bunnies.

(Ok actually that is probably a reason to vote Anya but vote Giles anyway)

[boondoggle]

Giles 5-
Anya/Anyanka 9

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Giles 5
Anya/Anyanka 8 -

[Pepsigirl]

Giles 4-
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Chiasm]

Giles 5+
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Callie]

Giles 6 +
Anya/Anyanka 8

[xakko]

Giles 6
Anya/Anyanka 9+

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Giles 6
Anya/Anyanka 8 -

[Pepsigirl]

Giles 5-
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Chiasm]

Giles 5
Anya/Anyanka 7-

[boondoggle]

Giles 4-
Anya/Anyanka 7

[tangentman]

Giles 4
Anya/Anyanka 8+

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Giles 4
Anya/Anyanka 7 -

[Chiasm]

*Jedi powers on*

Tara liked Giles more than Anya. Tara would vote for Giles

*Jedi powers off*

[Pepsigirl]

Giles 3-
Anya/Anyanka 7

[Chiasm]

Giles 4+
Anya/Anyanka 7

[xakko]

Giles 3-
Anya/Anyanka 7

[Pepsigirl]

*Jedi powers on*

Tara liked Giles more than Anya. Tara would vote for Giles

*Jedi powers off*

Tara sucked.

[Chiasm]

Tara sucked.

I'm trying to sucker Tangent. It probably won't work though.

[tangentman]

Giles 2-
Anya/Anyanka 7

Tara tried to accept Anya and wouldn't go for Chiasm's manipulative games. :p

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Giles 3 +
Anya/Anyanka 7

[Pepsigirl]

Giles 2-
Anya/Anyanka 7

[slively]

Giles 2
Anya/Anyanka 8 +

[Chiasm]

Giles 3+
Anya/Anyanka 8

[tangentman]

Giles 2-
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Chiasm]

If Anya wins I can live with it. I'll be happy knowing I led the assault on Buffy even if I didn't cast the final vote and I helped off Faith finally.

[Callie]

Giles 3 +
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Pepsigirl]

If Anya wins I can live with it. I'll be happy knowing I led the assault on Buffy even if I didn't cast the final vote and I helped off Faith finally.

Then give up on Giles. It'd take a miracle for him to win at this point.

And Faith lasting so long was pretty annoying.

[Pepsigirl]

Giles 2-
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Chiasm]

I'll keep fighting for Giles til the end. The Reaper never gives up.

But there is a certain irony of Anya winning if she does given she died such a meaningless death.

[slively]

Giles 1-
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Chiasm]

Giles 2+
Anya/Anyanka 8

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Giles 1 -
Anya/Anyanka 8


Curse you Chiasm!

You took away my killing of the Reaper!

[Pepsigirl]

But there is a certain irony of Anya winning if she does given she died such a meaningless death.

:( Thanks for bringing it up.

[tangentman]

Giles 0-
Anya/Anyanka 8


The winner is............


Anya

[Chiasm]

N/M

Curses. Betrayed by the Cleric. :evilangry

[Pepsigirl]

Wooooooohoooooooo! Go Anya!

[xakko]

Boy was I slow...

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

N/M

Curses. Betrayed by the Cleric. :evilangry


Bah, I sided with you through most of the entire game. Really, it was getting tedious what with us barely keeping Giles going.

I felt it was better to end it now then prolong the inevitable. :(

[Pepsigirl]

Boy was I slow...

You edited at superhuman speed, though.

[Chiasm]

Hey Tangent, if you do an Angel list where do the in between characters like Darla and Lindsey go?

[Deathstroke]

Well that was interesting.

Completely BS winner but interesting.

[Pepsigirl]

Well that was interesting.

Completely BS winner but interesting.

Who would you have preferred win?

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Hey Tangent, if you do an Angel list where do the in between characters like Darla and Lindsey go?


Both were good breifly, so I think that they should go on the list.

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Who would you have preferred win?


Angel. Or Giles.

[Pepsigirl]

Angel. Or Giles.

That wasn't really directed at you, but ok.

[Chiasm]

Both were good breifly, so I think that they should go on the list.

I agree but Angel is much harder to judge good and evil. Wesley was good most of the time but delved in the dark side. Lilah was evil most of the time but was somewhat redeemed at the end.

And is Illyria a seperate character from Fred? And is Illyria a good guy? Yeah she fought with the good guys but she was still evil?

I say just put all the major characters on the list and have at it.

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

I agree but Angel is much harder to judge good and evil. Wesley was good most of the time but delved in the dark side. Lilah was evil most of the time but was somewhat redeemed at the end.

And is Illyria a seperate character from Fred? And is Illyria a good guy? Yeah she fought with the good guys but she was still evil?

I say just put all the major characters on the list and have at it.


Agreed with the major character list.

Especially since Angel didn't have quite so many reacurring supporting good guys.

[Cleric of Hell's Brigade]

Illyria should be a seperate character IMO.

[Hi-Fi]

Holy Crap!!!

I can't believe she won and i wasn't even present!!!!

Go Anya!!!

[Hi-Fi]

I'm actually really happy. She died in the show but won in an online game! Everything is right in the world again!!

You fought well, Chiasm. ; )


Rob H will be happy. It's funny because he and I were trying to protect Anya during the entire game, and none of us were present in the final.

[Callie]

Illyria isn't Fred. It's a demon inhabiting a dead shell of a human. Illyria had access to Fred's memories, but really it was all Illyria and only the tiniest echo of Fred. Less mish-mashy blendy than a vampire who overtakes a human's body but keeps the memories, mind, and personality to a certain extent (less in Angel, more in Spike).

I got busy, so I couldn't help keep Giles going. I'm glad that one of the two won though. Giles and Anya are two of my favorite characters.

[Rob H]

Holy crap. What happened? I go out for a day and come back to see my favorite character on top!!! :)

[Rob H]

Rob H will be happy. It's funny because he and I were trying to protect Anya during the entire game, and none of us were present in the final.:D Piece of cake.

[Hi-Fi]

:D Piece of cake.

I thought she wouldn't make it to the final 3. :D

[tangentman]

Do you folks want me to post the Angel edition? My thoughts on the question of Good/Evil characters is that Angel treaded a grayer line in terms of morality than Buffy, though not as gray as Firefly. Characters of "evil" persuasion often seemed to function like "Supporting Cast Members" in terms of their interaction with the main Cast, receiving their own story arcs, and having an impact on the meta-arc. Lindsey, Lilah, Darla, and Illyria would be appropriate for the game for those reasons, imo.

[Chiasm]

Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!
Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel! Angel!

[PerfectBrak]

Do you folks want me to post the Angel edition? My thoughts on the question of Good/Evil characters is that Angel treaded a grayer line in terms of morality than Buffy, though not as gray as Firefly. Characters of "evil" persuasion often seemed to function like "Supporting Cast Members" in terms of their interaction with the main Cast, receiving their own story arcs, and having an impact on the meta-arc. Lindsey, Lilah, Darla, and Illyria would be appropriate for the game for those reasons, imo.

A nice list shouldn't be too hard to make either way. I'd even include the "big bads". Add all characters listed in the main credits, the supporters listed above and Skip, Gwen Raiden, The Beast, Kate, Eve, Holtz, Groo, Jasmine and you got a game.

[Rob H]

Yup. I'd love to see an Angel edition. Include the good and evil. Maybe even split Angel and Angelus into two different entries?

[Peter]

Giles 0-
Anya/Anyanka 8

The winner is............

Anya

And I wanted it to be Giles just to annoy you :p .

[tangentman]

I just wish the letter size could have been bigger when I typed super-sized "Anya".

[Davideaux]

It's a shame Anya won.

[Pepsigirl]

It's a shame Anya won.

It's not a shame, you're just annoyed because your favorite character didn't win.

[Peter]

It's not a shame, you're just annoyed because your favorite character didn't win.

Uh, isn't that the point to these things? I'm a little disappointed to, I mean Anya was cool (and given that Whedon should've been arrested for writing so awful it was criminal in killing her off, seeing her win was nifty) but sorry I was rootin' for Faith or Angel. Maybe Oz ( :evilangry ) to win.

[Deathstroke]

This thread should be locked off now that it's over.