rate the comic book movies

[sgt.candy]

from best to worst

Do it.

[Shellhead]

How about we generate a list of comic book movies first?

And maybe some criteria, too. Do you consider Ghost World, The Road to Perdition and Sin City to be comic book movies?

[sgt.candy]

How about we generate a list of comic book movies first?

And maybe some criteria, too. Do you consider Ghost World, The Road to Perdition and Sin City to be comic book movies?
yup yea sure

[Shellhead]

Okay, I will list all the comic movies that I can think of offhand, and others can add to the list, and then we can rank them.

List:

Spider-man
Spider-man 2
Fantastic Four
Batman (original)
Batman (Burton)
Batman Returns
Batman and Robin
Batman Begins
Blade
Blade II
Blade III
Superman
Superman II
Superman III
Superman IV
Hulk
Elektra
Daredevil
Alien vs. Predator
Hellboy
Ghost World
The Road to Perdition
Sin City
Spawn
Catwoman
X-Men
X-Men II
Punisher
Constantine
Swamp Thing
Man-Thing

there were a whole bunch of really crappy made-for-tv or direct-to-video superhero movies back in the 70's and 80's, but I don't know much about them.

[sgt.candy]

Spider-man 8
Spider-man 2 8.5
Fantastic Four 5
Batman (original) 2
Batman (Burton) 9.5
Batman Returns 3
Batman and Robin 1
Batman Begins 9.5
Blade 8
Blade II 2
Blade III 5
Superman 10
Superman II 8
Superman III 6
Superman IV 5
Hulk 4
Elektra 3
Daredevil 8.5
Alien vs. Predator 0
Hellboy 9.5
Ghost World 7
The Road to Perdition
Sin City 10
Spawn 4
Catwoman -2
X-Men 8.5
X-Men II 9.5
Punisher 4
Constantine 7
Swamp Thing NA
Man-Thing havent seen but im sure it sucks

[Smallville]

Ratings out of 10:

Spider-Man - 8
Spider-Man 2 - 9
Batman (1989) - 8
Batman Returns - 8
Batman Forever - 7.5
Batman and Robin - 5
Batman Begins - 10
Daredevil - 8.5
X-Men - 8
X-2 - 8
Fantastic 4 - 6
The Punisher - 8
Sin City - 10
The Hulk - 4
Superman - 9
Superman II - 7

[Shellhead]

Spider-man (9)
Spider-man 2 (didn't see)
Fantastic Four (didn't see)
Batman (original) (3)
Batman (Burton) (7)
Batman Returns (6)
Batman and Robin (didn't see)
Batman Begins (8)
Blade (didn't see)
Blade II (didn't see)
Blade III (5)
Superman (didn't see)
Superman II (didn't see)
Superman III (didn't see)
Superman IV (didn't see)
Hulk (didn't see)
Elektra (didn't see)
Daredevil (didn't see)
Alien vs. Predator (didn't see)
Hellboy (8.5)
Ghost World (7)
The Road to Perdition (didn't see)
Sin City (9)
Spawn (didn't see)
Catwoman (didn't see)
X-Men (7.5)
X-Men II (7)
Punisher (didn't see)
Constantine (didn't see)
Swamp Thing (didn't see)
Man-Thing (didn't see)

[Cash Lone]

Spider-man - 7
Spider-man 2 - 1
Fantastic Four - 1
Batman (original) - 7
Batman (Burton) - 7
Batman Returns - 8
Batmna Forever - 5
Batman and Robin - 4
Batman Begins - 6
Blade II - 5
Hulk - 5
Daredevil - 7
Ghost World - 10
Sin City - 10
X-Men - 6
X-Men II - 8
Punisher - 5

I've seen all the Superman films as a kid, but its been so long I didnt feel it was right to rate them since my memory is hazy on them.

[stealthwise]

Spider-man - 7
Spider-man 2 - 6
Batman (Burton) - 8
Batman Returns - 7
Batman and Robin - 0
Batman Begins - 10
Blade - 10
Blade II - 8
Blade III - 6
Superman - 8
Superman II - 8
Superman III - 3
Superman IV - 5
Hulk - 5
Daredevil - 6
Hellboy - 7
Ghost World - 9
The Road to Perdition - 7
Sin City - 9
Spawn - 6
X-Men - 9
X-Men II - 10
Punisher - 6

[Asian Knight]

Spider-man 7
Spider-man 2 7
Fantastic Four (Roger Corburn) 2 (Marvel) 9
Batman (original) 8
Batman (Burton) 9
Batman Returns 9
Batman and Robin 5
Batman Begins 10
Blade 7
Blade II 7
Blade III 5 (Liked the alt ending better)
Superman 7
Superman II 7
Superman III 7
Superman IV 7
Hulk 1 (Badly done)
Elektra 9
Daredevil 9
Alien vs. Predator 5
Hellboy 8
Ghost World (Haven't seen it)
The Road to Perdition (Havnen't seen it)
Sin City 9
Spawn 7
Catwoman 8
X-Men 7
X-Men II 7
Punisher (Dolph version 4, Thomas Jane version 9)
Constantine 8
Swamp Thing 8
Man-Thing (Forgot to catch it on Sci-Fi)

[choptop]

Spider-man -6
Spider-man 2 -5
Fantastic Four - 1
Batman (original) - 6
Batman (Burton) -8
Batman Returns - 8
Batmna Forever - 9
Batman and Robin - 3
Batman Begins - 10
Blade II - 6
Hulk - 2
Daredevil - 3
bladeI-6
Sin City - 10
X-Men -5
X-Men II -6
Punisher -3
bladeIII-4
catwomen-4 Man-Thing-2

[Nick Kal]

Your forgot Batman Forever, Captain America and Supergirl!

[Zun Liako]

Spider-man - 8
Spider-man 2 - 8.5
Fantastic Four - 5
Batman (original)- 2
Batman (Burton) - 8
Batman Returns - 7.5
Batman and Robin - -10
Batman Begins - 10
Blade- 7
Blade II-6
Blade III - 3
Superman- 9
Superman II - 8
Superman III - 4
Superman IV - 3
Hulk - 7
Elektra - 5
Daredevil - 6
Alien vs. Predator -2
Hellboy- 9
Ghost World -6
The Road to Perdition -7.5
Sin City-10
Spawn - 4
Catwoman - -10
X-Men - 9
X-Men II - 9.5
Punisher- 7
Constantine - 7
Swamp Thing - Never saw
Man-Thing- never saw

[Ravenheart]

Spider-man-8
Spider-man 2-10
Fantastic Four-7
Batman (original)-8
Batman (Burton)-8
Batman Returns-7
Batman and Robin-6
Batman Begins-8
Blade-7
Blade II-6
Blade III-7
Superman-9
Superman II-10
Superman III-6
Superman IV-6
Hulk-7
Elektra-6
Daredevil-7
Alien vs. Predator-7
Hellboy-8
Ghost World-didn't see it
The Road to Perdition-didn't see it
Sin City-10
Spawn-6
Catwoman-0
X-Men-8
X-Men II-8
Punisher-8
Constantine-6
Swamp Thing-7
Man-Thing-7

[dougiemccoy]

List:

Spider-man 8.5 would be better with out the webbing that come out hands
Spider-man 2 7.5 loved the doc ock
Fantastic Four 7 just didn't like dr. doom as much as i should
Batman (original) 7 some days you just can't get rid of a bomb i love this stuff when i was a kid
Batman (Burton) 8.5
Batman Returns 8 not as good as the first
Batman and Robin 6 not as good as the second
Batman Begins 6 ok better than B&R
Blade 8 this kick butt i mean he killed what 30 badguys in the forst 5 min. of the movie
Blade II 8
Blade III 8
Superman 8
Superman II 8.5
Superman III 5 lame
Superman IV 5 just as lame
Hulk 7.5 loved hulk vs the army sences if the end was as good as this part i would a lot happer hopefully 2 will have lots more this
Elektra didseeit
Daredevil 8.5 now i really liked this don't know why some many fanboys didn't
Alien vs. Predator didn'tseeit
Hellboy 9 great stuff
Ghost World 7
The Road to Perdition 8
Sin City 10 this is as good as it gets
Spawn 6 hey it better than the comic
Catwoman didn'tseeit
X-Men 9 love the sence where the Nazi was taking Mag. from his mom and dad
X-Men II 9
Punisher 4 man this sucked
Constantine didn'tseeit
Swamp Thing 6 just because what her name boobs
Man-Thing 3

[LordEd1976]

Batman Begins: A+
Batman (Burton): A
Batman (West/Ward): B-
Batman Returns: B-
Batman Forever: C
Batman and Robin: F
Batman Mask of the Phantasm: A+
Superman (Chris Reeves): A
Superman 2: A+
Superman 3: D
Superman 4: D
Captain America: F (Red Skull is GERMAN!! twit)
XMen: A
X2: A
Spider-Man: B
Spider-Man 2: A-
Alien vs. Predator: F
Hulk: D
Punisher (80s): F
Punisher (Thomas Jane): D
Hellboy: B
Daredevil: C
Elektra: D
Road to Perdition: A

[Buzz Dixon]

I'm just gonna group 'em, I'm not gonna try to rank 'em.

Best Superhero Movies:
CAPTAIN MARVEL (serial)
BATMAN (Adam West)
IT'S A BIRD! IT'S A PLANE! IT'S SUPERMAN! (made for TV movie based on the Broadway musical)
SUPERMAN (Christopher Reeves)
X-MEN 1 & 2
SPIDER-MAN 1 & 2

Best Horror:
DR. STRANGE
CEMETARY MAN (based on DYLAN DOG)

Best Drama:
GHOST WORLD
THE ROAD TO PERDITION
AMERICAN SPLENDOR

Best Sci-Fi:
FLASH GORDON (original 3 serials)
BUCK ROGERS (serial)

Guiltiest Pleasures:
WONDER WOMAN (Cathy Lee Crosby version)
HOWARD THE DUCK
VAMPIRELLA
NICK FURY, AGENT OF S.H.I.E.L.D.

[Lord_Archive]

My Top Twenty:

1. X2: X-men united
2. Sin City
3. Batman (1989)
4. Hulk
5. Batman Begins
6. Blade
7. Hellboy
8. X-men
9. Spider-Man
10. Blade II
11. Mystery Men
12. The Mask
13. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
14. Daredevil
15. The Punisher (2004)
16. Spider-Man II
17. Fantastic Four
18. Conan the Barbarian
19. Superman II
20. Spawn

[tangentman]

Spider-man-7
Spider-man2-9
Fantastic Four-6
Batman (original)-4
Batman (Burton)-8
Batman Returns-9
Batman and Robin-6
Batman Begins-10
Blade-9
Blade II-6
Blade III-5
Superman-8
Superman II-8
Superman III-5
Superman IV-3
Hulk-7
Elektra-5
Daredevil-6
Alien vs. Predator (didn't see)
Hellboy-8
Ghost World-10
The Road to Perdition (didn't see)
Sin City-10
Spawn (didn't see)
Catwoman-3
X-Men-7
X-Men II-9
Punisher-7
Constantine (didn't see)
Swamp Thing-4
Man-Thing-0