X-Men Popularity Tournament round 1

[Blackcat]

You vote for the one (of two) you like more, not who's the strongest one in a fight. We start with the women of X

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[Blackcat]

My selection is:

Jean Grey
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Sage
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Martha
Thornn
Meltdown
Magma
Husk
Penance
Dani
Bling
Lee Forester
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Lifeguard
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[Christopher O]

I'll bite...

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wallflower - Mercury (You meant Wallflower, right?)
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust (I assume you mean Revanche)
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[Huzzah!]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Sage
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Martha
Thornn
Syrin
Karma
Husk
Monet
Dani
X-23
Lee Forester
Shard
Dust
Darkstar
Lifeguard
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[Sion]

Jean Grey
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Winddancer
Wildflower
Angel
Martha
Thornn
Syrin
Magma
Jubilee
Penance
Wolfsbane
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[Tobias March]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury?don't know
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

There are one or two there I don't recognize, but that's it. Claremount did introduce some great female characters in his time - pity most of them have dropped off the radar.

[jeangreydp]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby- I can't pick they're both pure evil.
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[eyril]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[Mike Smash!]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Dazzler
Rachel
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Ernst
Thornn
Syrin
Magma
Jubilee
Monet
Wolfsbane
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Lifeguard
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[EvilDangerRoom]

Jean Grey
Polaris
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Surge
Wildflower
Angel
Martha
Feral
Syrin
Magma
Husk
Monet
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie
Cuckoos

[Stoss]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[Pepsigirl]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

All this does is prove that there are a TON of X-Women that I could care less about.

[Bart Simpson]

Jean Grey
Polaris
Rogue
Dazzler
Sage
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Martha
Feral
Syrin
Karma
Husk
Penance
Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23- NEITHER
Moria
Cecelia Reyes
Dust
Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Tattoo

[Nyssane]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Dazzler
Rachel
Wind Dancer
Mercury
Rubbermaid
Ernst
Thornn
Syrin
Karma
Jubilee
Monet
Wolfsbane
X-23
Moira
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Magik I
Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander
Trish Tilby
Tattoo

[fishtaco]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Siryn
Magma
Jubilee
Penance
Mirage
X-23
Moira MacTaggert
Shard
Dust
'Yana
Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Annie
Cuckoos

Kinda a random list. Some charaters I picked that I dont like, because the other one is worse, IMO. I had trouble over Rachel and Sage.

[LordAllMighty]

IMHO,

Jean Grey
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Sage
Winddancer
Mercury
Angel
Martha
Thornn
Meltdown
Karma
Jubilee
Monet
Wolfsbane
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Revance
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie
Cuckoos

[thik_3rd]

Jean Grey
Polaris
Rogue
Dazzler
Rachel
Surge ???
Wildflower ???
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Syrin
Magma
Jubilee
Monet
Wolfsbane
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Revance
Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Tattoo

[venuscameback]

I'll go with ...

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo


where i've not emboldened either name it's because i hate them equally.

presumbly Moria is a typo for Moira and not a character I'm unfamiliar with? I'm thinking moira because that makes the coupling two non-powered x-allies.

most difficult choice to make: Rachel or Sage

Rachel's one of my favourite characters but I haven't seen her do much in Uncanny so ... Sage won through. for the moment.


venus

[Blackcat]

Rachel's one of my favourite characters but I haven't seen her do much in Uncanny so ... Sage won through. for the moment.


I know some choises are hard to make, or you hate them both, or love 'em both, but the list is random, I mixed them up and put draw the names by two.

Monday I will add the votes up and you'll have to choose between the ones which are left, until we have 5 left...

After this I will do the same with the guys, foes and as last the villian-teams.

So let your voice be heard!!!

[silverbolt]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[Tenebrae]

Jean Grey
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Sage
Winddancer
Mercury
Rubbermaid
Martha
Thornn
Syrin
Karma
Husk
Penance
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[Dizzy D]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Winddancer
Mercury
Rubbermaid
Ernst
Thornn
Syrin
Karma
Husk
Penance
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Sharon Friedlander (oddly the most difficult choice for me, I like them both)
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

The Big Missing: Emma Frost? Where is she?

[Shadow Crawler]

Shadowcat
Polaris
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Winddancer
Mercury
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Syrin
Karma
Jubilee
Monet
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie
Cuckoos

[AnthonyJ]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Martha
Feral
Syrin
Karma
Jubilee
Penance
Dani
X-23
Lee Forester
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[Magpie]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

If no one's bolded, it's because I don't have a clue who either one is. :p
Is Emma being considered a foe?

[Taltos]

Jean Grey
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Martha
Feral
Syrin
Magma
Husk
Monet
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie
Cuckoos

[countryfan2004]

Shadowcat
Storm
Marrow
Psylocke
Rachel
Surge
Mercury
Rubbermaid
Martha
Feral
Siryn
Magma
Husk
Monet
Wolfsbane
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Revanche
Illyana/ Magik I
Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[milhouse123321]

Shadowcat
Polaris
Rogue
Dazzler
Rachel
Surge
Mercury
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Meltdown
Magma
Husk
Monet
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie
Tattoo

[tangentman]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Dazzler
Rachel
Winddancer
Wildflower
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Syrin
Magma
Husk
Monet
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Daytripper/ Magik II
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

[chicainery]

Did you know that this has already been done here?

Round by Round results can be found here:

Finals: http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=47587&highlight=X-Pop

Semi-finals: http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=47076&highlight=X-Pop

Quarter-finals: http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=46547&highlight=X-Pop
http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=46056&highlight=X-Pop

Round two: http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=45351&highlight=X-Pop

Round one: http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?t=44932&highlight=X-Men+Popularity


And the winner...

Ladies and Gentlemen, we have a winner.

So, without further ado, let's hear it for the winner IS...

Lovely, talented, cute spunky...

Kitty Pryde

So, um there you have it

let the "oh the popularity contest run by someone with Kitty Pryde in their name was won by Kitty... whatashocker" posts begin!

[bagheera]

Shadowcat
Storm
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Windancer
Wildflower
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Siryn
Magma
Jubilee
Monet
Dani
X23
Miora
Cecelia Reyes
Dust
Illyana
Lifeguard
Stevie Hunter
TRish Tilby
Cuckoos

[iGotKittyPryde]

Shadowcat
Polaris
Rogue
Psylocke
Rachel
Winddancer
Mercury
Angel
Ernst
Feral
Syrin
Magma
Jubilee
Monet
Dani
X-23
Moria
Cecilia Reyes
Dust
Illyana/ Magik I
Magik II - Lifeguard
Stevie Hunter
Trish Tilby
Cuckoos

How'd you figure out who went against who? Cause Jean vs. Kitty is a bit rough for the first round? Was it random? That's what I did when I did basically the exact same thing as this a few months ago (although I'll admit, you're better at bringing in the obscure (and even some non-obscure ones I missed) characters)

[Blackcat]

How'd you figure out who went against who? Cause Jean vs. Kitty is a bit rough for the first round? Was it random? That's what I did when I did basically the exact same thing as this a few months ago (although I'll admit, you're better at bringing in the obscure (and even some non-obscure ones I missed) characters)

Allready answered that question, I just mixed them up and put them in two rows. The only 3 catagories I made were human friens, students and x-women.

[actionpad]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo

[North]

Shadowcat or Jean Grey dang tough one
Storm - Polaris
Marrow - Rogue
Dazzler - Psylocke
Rachel - Sage
Surge - Winddancer
Wildflower - Mercury
Rubbermaid - Angel
Ernst - Martha neither
Thornn - Feral
Syrin - Meltdown
Magma - Karma
Jubilee - Husk
Monet - Penance
Dani - Wolfsbane
Bling - X-23 you mean blink?
Moria - Lee Forester
Shard - Cecilia Reyes
Revance - Dust
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby
Cuckoos - Tattoo[/QUOTE]

[Blackcat]

In one hour I'll close this part and will start the follow-up...!


.

[Blackcat]

NO MORE VOTING

The votes are being counted for round two

[Blackcat]

The name in bold has won the battle and will go to the next fase of this tournement. Behind the names you will see the scores.

Shadowcat - Jean Grey (equal scores: 15/15, both will go to the next round!)
Storm - Polaris (20/10)
Marrow - Rogue (1/29)
Dazzler - Psylocke (9/21)
Rachel - Sage (20/10)
Surge - Winddancer (16/14)
Wildflower - Mercury (7/22)
Rubbermaid - Angel (6/23)
Ernst - Martha (16/12)
Thornn - Feral 9/20)
Syrin - Meltdown (24/5) Almost no fans of Meltdown, suprised me..
Magma - Karma (18/12)
Jubilee - Husk (19/10)
Monet - Penance (20/10)
Dani - Wolfsbane (18/12)
Bling - X-23 (7/22)
Moira - Lee Forester (28/2)
Shard - Cecilia Reyes (5/25)
Revance - Dust (4/25)
Illyana/ Magik I - Darkstar (26/4)
Daytripper/ Magik II - Lifeguard (19/8)
Sharon Friedlander - Stevie Hunter (3/27)
Nurse Annie - Trish Tilby (7/22)
Cuckoos - Tattoo (25/5)

[Blackcat]

Because Jean and Shadowcat had an equal score, I will need to add one more to the next round and decided to take the one with the smalest differance with her opponant, in this case: Surge - Winddancer (16/14), so Winddancer will also go to the next round.

.

[Blackcat]

The second round has started: http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showthread.php?p=1621207#post1621207