PDA

View Full Version : A quick word on banning


Matt
06-16-2005, 06:54 PM
Occassionally there is a need to ban certain people from these forums. There are standards of behaviour that are expected and when those expectations are not met, the user is banned.

For smaller breaches the moderators impose a temporary ban which can last from one day to usually a week. For larger breaches, permanent bans are used.

Any attempt to bypass any ban, temporary or permanent, will result in an IP Ban being placed which will stop any access to the forums. I do not like enforcing IP Bans because they have the potential of stopping the access of innocent people on the same ISP - however, if it stops access to those not mature enough to accept the consequences of their actions then so be it.

In 90% of cases, we quickly spot those who have complete lack of common sense and proceed to create a second account. There are numerous give-aways we can identify easily and, sooner or later, we will spot anyone evading a ban.

So if you happen to be banned, don't be a jackass and try to come back. You were barred for a good reason. Instead, try contacting the Moderator in question and asking. If necessary, send a polite letter to Jonah (whose email adress is viewable at all times) asking about the situation.
I am also always available for such questions and I'm far less busy than Jonah. I can be contacted at mattcbr@gmail.com.

I should also point out that the Moderators will not publicise who has been banned or for what reasons. We will not spend time contacting banned users explaining the reasons for the ban since they should be able to work it out for themselves easily enough.

grendel824
06-17-2005, 02:35 AM
Whoa! You read my mind - I just recently saw a bunch of posts by people with a line through their names and got curious as to why they were banned, but a quick post-history search showed nothing... should I assume the offending posts were just deleted?

I knew there was a reason why this was a much better environment than comicon (where I was stalked, threatened, had my parents' home address posted with an invitation to kill them, etc., and was then banned for complaining about nothing being done about it).

Dee3
06-17-2005, 11:20 AM
I agree grendal though I have been wondering about some of my friends and hope that I am not ban worthy yet though there have been posts that I regret.

DarkBlade
06-17-2005, 06:23 PM
Yup. Generally speaking, if you're saying something banworthy, it's not going to stay on the board either.

Brandon Hanvey
06-17-2005, 07:07 PM
The basic rule to follow is to be civil. But there are some CBR Forum guidelines (http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showpost.php?p=1459763&postcount=3) which you can follow. Keep in mind that certain boards are more strict about langauge than others such as the Spider-man and Marvel forums. There usuall is a sticky on top of the board that outlines what is and is not okay to post.

Matt
06-17-2005, 09:44 PM
...hope that I am not ban worthy yet...

If you were ban worthy, then you'd already be banned.
Relax.

Matt
06-17-2005, 09:55 PM
Over the past couple of days, there has been an example of how not to handle being banned.

I received a request to ban a certain user for one day. Had a quick look, saw that a ban was fitting and placed the requested one day ban.
That user then proceeded to create a second account. This second account was quickly spotted and banned. The user ended up sending a quite abusive email to the moderator who requested the ban.

Which has now resulted in an IP ban being put in place.

Which is quite unfortunate since it could possibly affect completely innocent people who use the same ISP as the banned user.

So instead of being mature by copping a one day ban on the chin and learning from his mistakes, this user is now completely barred from the forums just because he could not behave in a civilised manner.

Ouzo Man
06-23-2005, 02:47 PM
Once I got a message I was banned. Never did find out why, so it might have been a technical glitch or a collateral ban based on an IP address.

If I had been banned for cause, however, my response may have aided my getting un-banned. I sent a polite email asking if I had done something and if there was someone I needed to apologize to or otherwise set matters right.

I never did find out what was up, so maybe it was someone got ill while trying to eat and reading some completely reprehensible posting I may (or may not) have put up about Don Knotts in lingerie, or something similarly unnecessary.

But the point is be a grown up about it and you'll be better off.