X

[SUPERMAN PRIME]

there was a mini called "The Brotherhood" was written by a guy who used the nick X...does anyone know his real name ?

[Sheldon]

Read the FAQ here (http://forums.comicbookresources.com/showpost.php?p=269917&postcount=8)

[SUPERMAN PRIME]

thanks
why do u think a writer wouldnt tell his name ?

the brotherhood wasnt so good but that doesnt mean anything .

i think that he was a big name who tried to do something different without facing the consequences of failure

[The Lucky One]

thanks
why do u think a writer wouldnt tell his name ?

Because it was Howard Mackie, probably. Or some other writer who knew he had a less-than-stellar reputation among X-fans, but wanted to try something new without any preconceptions coloring people's opinions. And then when it wasn't successful, didn't want credit for it.

-D

[fishtaco]

thanks
why do u think a writer wouldnt tell his name ?

the brotherhood wasnt so good but that doesnt mean anything .

i think that he was a big name who tried to do something different without facing the consequences of failureIt was never revealed.

[Michael P]

I hear it was Alan Smithee.

[The_15th_Sven]

Had something, deleted it.

[Sharcque]

Dunno why, but I've been under the assumption that it was Mackie.....I thought that it had been revealed.

[mattbib]

I thought that it had been revealed.Nope. Still open for speculation.

[StoneGold]

It was Steve Ditko. And until you can find me a picture of the two of them together, prove me wrong.