PDA

View Full Version : Defining Earth-2: Your Opinions, Please


Cei-U!
03-17-2005, 09:07 PM
I'm trying to write a rough draft of what will eventually be the introductory essay to my Collectors' Guide to Earth-2. Although that project is too far from completion to allow me to flesh the essay out with specifics, I have cobbled an outline together that hopefully touches all the bases. I thought I'd offer this preliminary outline here and ask you folks for some feedback. Ergo:

I. Origins
..A. The Creative Force and the Primal Atom
..B. Krona and the Multiverse

II. Religion
..A. Heaven and Hell
..B. Souls
....1. Reincarnation
....2. Ghosts

III. Magic
..A. Order and Chaos
..B. The Green Flame of Life
..C. The Spear of Destiny
..D. Mythological Races
....1. The Olympian (Greco-Roman) Pantheon
....2. Norse, Egyptian and Other Pantheons
....3. Monsters

IV. Physics
..A. Faster-than-light travel
..B. Time travel
..C. Interdimensional travel
..D. Psi

V. Geography and Ethnology
..A. Nations
..B. Cities
....1. Metropolis
....2. Gotham City
..C. Hidden Races
....1. Amazons of Paradise Island
....2. Feithera
....3. Aquatic Races
....4. Subterranean Races

VI. History and Legend
..A. Vandal Savage
..B. Atlantis and Lemuria
..C. The Trojan War and the Odyssey
..D. King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table
..E. Robin Hood and the Merrie Men

VII. Beyond Earth-2
..A. The Solar System
..B. Extraterrestrial Races

VIII. Superhumans and Mystery Men
..A. The Justice Society of America
..B. Infinity Inc.
..C. The Seven Soldiers of Victory
..D. The Freedom Fighters
..E. The All-Star Squadron
..G. The Injustice Society of the World/The Crime Champions
..H. The Secret Society of Super-Villains

IX. The Multiverse
..A. Doppelgängers
..B. Earth-1
..C. Earth-X
..D. Earth-3
..E. Earth-S
..F. Earth-Prime
..G. The Fifth Dimension
..H. Other Parallel and Alternate Universes

X. The Future
..A. Alternate timelines
..B. The Crisis on Infinite Earths
..C. The Modern DC Universe

Sorry about the formatting. So whaddayathink?

Cei-U!
I summon the big damn writing job!

MWGallaher
03-18-2005, 06:34 AM
It looks great! I look forward to seeing the final version of this very much!

But since you're looking for suggestions rather than advance praise for the project, here are some things that you might want to consider:

Superhumans and Mystery Men: Shouldn't you mention the Super-Squad here? I don't remember if that was ever a formal designation in the actual comic book, but even if it wasn't, the name should be explained.

Religion: I'm sure Badhnesia will be covered under "Nations", but don't forget that it appears to have been something of a theocracy practicing a unique religion focused largely on Johnny Thunder! That might warrant a mention in section II.

Slam_Bradley
03-18-2005, 07:21 AM
The only thing that struck me on first glance was the ordering of the Super Groups. I realize that Infinity Inc. is the spiritual heir of the JSA, but I think a chronological ordering might be a little easier to understand, and is more consistent with what you're doing in the "History and Legend" section.

My two bits.

Jonathan Bogart
03-18-2005, 09:35 AM
The only thing that came to mind was that a cuter name for "Beyond Earth-2" might be "Universe-2."

Well, that and my dislike for the entire Earth-2 concept (with all due respect to Gardner Fox). I like the JSA (and similar Golden-Age heroes) as pulp characters in the late 30s and 40s: after that, my interest flags fast.

But that's my problem.