PDA

View Full Version : Incredible Hulk



negation
02-28-2010, 10:37 AM
I am enjoying this series so far, I absolutly love PPs art ( and team ). There are a few things that bug me,
Pak-his writing is all over the place,
1) Skarr is supposed to be more of a monster but just seems like Green Scar from Planet hulk
2) Power level-in Son Of Hulk Skarr did not seem to be in the Hulk class, now he does
3) Old Power-in the beginning it seemed to be a mystical power locked to a planet, now its supposed to be a scientific replica of the power cosmic, explain
4) Bruce Banner is way out of charecter, and way to smart. Coming up with force fields, teleportaion devices etc, seems more like what a gamma radiated genius like the Leader should be able to do not a really brilliant earth scientist ( a phsicist specializing in Gamma research no less, explain................

Pak's writing is threatning to ruin my enjoyment of this series, he is taking to many liberties with abilities and giving very little explanation.

Talkie Toaster
02-28-2010, 10:53 AM
1) Skarr is supposed to be more of a monster but just seems like Green Scar from Planet hulk

I'd withhold that judgement for a while. It seems to me that we haven't seen Skaar show all his cards yet.


2) Power level-in Son Of Hulk Skarr did not seem to be in the Hulk class, now he does

I don't know, he seemed pretty strong on Sakaar and he seems pretty strong on Earth. And why shouldn't he have Hulk strength? His daddy does.


3) Old Power-in the beginning it seemed to be a mystical power locked to a planet, now its supposed to be a scientific replica of the power cosmic, explain

Did you read the Son of Hulk story starring Hulks other son, Hiro? I think that explained it pretty well. Better than I could certainly.


4) Bruce Banner is way out of charecter, and way to smart. Coming up with force fields, teleportaion devices etc, seems more like what a gamma radiated genius like the Leader should be able to do not a really brilliant earth scientist ( a phsicist specializing in Gamma research no less, explain................

The Leader probably did come up with a lot of that tech. It has already been said that Banner reverse engineered his teleportation device from the Leader's. And later we see him raiding one of the Leader's lairs for info on Skaar. So obviously he's not above stealing from his enemies.

Drdmx
02-28-2010, 10:57 AM
4) Bruce Banner is way out of charecter, and way to smart. Coming up with force fields, teleportaion devices etc, seems more like what a gamma radiated genius like the Leader should be able to do not a really brilliant earth scientist ( a phsicist specializing in Gamma research no less, explain................

Pak's writing is threatning to ruin my enjoyment of this series, he is taking to many liberties with abilities and giving very little explanation.

Talkie handeled most of these alright. However, Bruce Banner has ALWAYS been this smart. He's just never been written this way. For those of us who have read Hulk for an extended amount of time, we get kind of giddy when a new aspect of his psyche (READ: That works for the character) is produced... and this one seems to do the trick! Banner isnt just smart in this new IH Book. He's kind of dark... and it not only bears looking into further, its actually interesting!

Talkie Toaster
02-28-2010, 11:12 AM
Talkie handeled most of these alright. However, Bruce Banner has ALWAYS been this smart. He's just never been written this way. For those of us who have read Hulk for an extended amount of time, we get kind of giddy when a new aspect of his psyche (READ: That works for the character) is produced... and this one seems to do the trick! Banner isnt just smart in this new IH Book. He's kind of dark... and it not only bears looking into further, its actually interesting!


No doubt Banner could invent some nifty gizmo's too. I'm just pointing out that even if you don't believe that Banner could come up with all that stuff or that he had enough time to do it, there have already been in-continuity explanations that he wouldn't even need to build it all from scratch. He could just rob old man Sterns :biggrin:

FlyingFox
02-28-2010, 12:57 PM
Talkie handeled most of these alright. However, Bruce Banner has ALWAYS been this smart. He's just never been written this way. For those of us who have read Hulk for an extended amount of time, we get kind of giddy when a new aspect of his psyche (READ: That works for the character) is produced... and this one seems to do the trick! Banner isnt just smart in this new IH Book. He's kind of dark... and it not only bears looking into further, its actually interesting!

I too like the smart kind-of dark Banner.

Doc Goblin
02-28-2010, 02:55 PM
1) Skarr is supposed to be more of a monster but just seems like Green Scar from Planet hulk

I think Skaar's character has been pretty consistent. He is still more of a monster than Hulk. He's completely willing to kill. But there's less opportunity for him to act the monster on Earth than hellish Sakaar. All he wants to do on Earth is kill the Hulk. He has no interest in making the whole planet pay or anything like he did on Sakaar.


2) Power level-in Son Of Hulk Skarr did not seem to be in the Hulk class, now he does

You have to remember that Skaar is still technically a child. He's growing. So he's only going to get stronger as time goes on.


3) Old Power-in the beginning it seemed to be a mystical power locked to a planet, now its supposed to be a scientific replica of the power cosmic, explain

Wasn't this explained by Old Sam or someone back in Skaar: Son of Hulk? The Shadow People created the Oldpower in some attempt to replicate the Power Cosmic and use it throughout the universe to hold together dying worlds. Some came to Sakaar and saved it from destruction, but over time most Shadow People forgot their scientific ways and more and more turned to faith and mysticism.


4) Bruce Banner is way out of charecter, and way to smart. Coming up with force fields, teleportaion devices etc, seems more like what a gamma radiated genius like the Leader should be able to do not a really brilliant earth scientist ( a phsicist specializing in Gamma research no less,

Bruce Banner is supposed to be one of the smartest guys around, and it's not like he's doing anything that extreme. The dude has a few cool gadgets. The teleporter, probably the most extreme of his gadgets, was immediately explained as being reverse-engineered from the Leader. I don't think the Oldpower blaster or force field are particularly out there.

Banner is acting darker and angrier than usual, but that's exactly how he should be acting. He can't become the Hulk. His anger doesn't get that release anymore. We don't usually get to see a Banner who has to deal with his own anger. Apparently, it makes him rather mean and hardcore.