How would Planet Hulk have gone with an different incarnation of the Hulk?

[seekquaze]

One reason Hulk was able to become a hero on Skaar was due to being an intelligent, yet powerful incarnation.

However, in an issue of Son of Hulk, Caira's spirit commented she came to understand why the Hulk was banished from Earth.

Without getting into that how do you think Planet Hulk would have gone if one if these versions had manifested on Skaar? What about after the Red King had been defeated and the Hulk reverted to one of these versons? How would Caira and the Warbond react to him? If he began to rampage would they have tried to reason with him or fought him? What if he got too dangerous? I'm curious as to when he first arrived and after he became king.

Classic savage Hulk/turns to Banner when calm
Permanent Savage Hulk
Bannerless Hulk/animal like intelligence
Constantly rampaging/angry at everything Hulk
Professor Hulk
Grey hulk bound by sunlight rules
Permanent Grey Hulk

How would things have turned out differnetly? Is there any case where the Warbound would have to destroy the Hulk or think he had to be stopped/removed from the planet despite their friendship?


Posted with Mozilla Firefox 3.5.2 on Windows XP

[Drdmx]

I think about every incarnation of the Hulk would have been about fine short of the Savage, but that's only because he reverts to Banner.

I think Banner addressed alot of why you saw the original personality of the Hulk there though during Banner wars and the point where Hulk mentions to Miek that Banner wouldnt last one second on Sakaar.

[Talkie Toaster]

Gray Hulk probably wouldn't fare too well as he's the weakest incarnation of the Hulk and Sakaar was a pretty tough place. He's also the meanest of all Hulks so I doubt he'd do anything self-sacrificing like letting the spikes feed of him.

The savage incarnations mostly want to be left alone so I doubt they'd want to be the green king (assuming they even understand the concept).

And obviously turning into Banner wouldn't have been a good idea on Sakaar.

The only other Hulk I can see doing a good job on Sakaar would have been merged/professor Hulk