PDA

View Full Version : chornological order

nam42589
08-19-2009, 10:21 AM
could someone please help me put these in chronological order?

Batgirl debuts
Robin(grayson) debuts
Robin(grayson) leaves
Robin(Jason Todd) debuts
Robin(Jason Todd) dies
Robin (Tim Drake) debuts
Nightwing(grayson) debuts


when does batgirl get shot is it after nightwing debuts or before Tim drake debuts?
ScottyQuick
08-19-2009, 10:27 AM
It's

Robin (Grayson)
Batgirl (Barbara)
Robin (Grayson) leaves
Robin (Todd) enters
Nightwing (Grayson) enters
Batgirl (Barbara) crippled
Tim Drake enters
Robin (Todd) is killed
Oracle enters
Robin (Tim) enters

I think.
AvengingAngel
08-19-2009, 10:28 AM
Robin (grayson) debuts
Batgirl debuts
Robin (grayson) leaves
Nightwing (grayson) debuts
Robin (Todd) debuts
Batgirl is shot
Robin (Todd) dies
Robin (Drake) debuts
nam42589
08-19-2009, 10:36 AM
i thought Grayson wasnt there when barbara got shot, didnt he say that to her? "I wish I could've been there" I thought he was with the Titans or something....?
shaxper
08-19-2009, 11:14 AM
i thought Grayson wasnt there when barbara got shot, didnt he say that to her? "I wish I could've been there" I thought he was with the Titans or something....?


He wasn't THERE (nor was Batman), but he was around.

Avenging Angel's continuity is correct.

Incidentally, Barbara being crippled and Todd's death happened VERY close together, so much so that there wasn't an opportunity to address the crippling in the comics while Todd's death was being dealt with. Since Barbara was crippled in a graphic novel, and since it wasn't addressed in the comics right after, it took a while before the whole thing was clearly acknowledged in comic continuity.
nam42589
08-19-2009, 11:48 AM
my question is though was nighwing in gotham when barbara got shot, and jason todd died or was he in bludhaven or on other planets with the titans?

cuz i thought i read a nightwing annual and he said he didnt find out about it till later because he was on another planet with the titans or somethin
shaxper
08-19-2009, 12:29 PM
my question is though was nighwing in gotham when barbara got shot, and jason todd died or was he in bludhaven or on other planets with the titans?

cuz i thought i read a nightwing annual and he said he didnt find out about it till later because he was on another planet with the titans or somethin

Dick was stationed in New York with the New Titans (Bludhaven hadn't even been created by the writers yet). I believe Dick is referring to the "Who is Wondergirl?" storyline that had the Titans out in space for a number of issues. I'm pretty sure this happened around the same time that Barbara was crippled.