PDA

View Full Version : Amy Reeder Hadley on Batgirl/Gotham City Sirens

mofo
06-10-2009, 04:16 AM
Good idea, no?

edit 1: she's got a very graceful, colorful style... which is why I'm proposing the idea

edit 2: actually.... she would also be rather good on Batman & Robin.... :D
JumpingJupiter
06-10-2009, 04:31 AM
I'd buy that.
ScottyQuick
06-10-2009, 06:41 AM
Isn't she busy over on Madame Xanadu?
mofo
06-10-2009, 08:27 AM
well she didn't draw the last issue, and isn't gonna draw the next 3
FanboyStranger
06-10-2009, 08:35 AM
Kaluta is just filling in for five issues on Mdme X. I would greatly prefer if Hadley stayed on Mdme X-- it's the best DCU book currently being published, in my opinion, even though it's Vertigo-- but if she does move on (or if Mdme X is cancelled), this would be a good book to assign to her.
Quinnhop
06-10-2009, 08:41 AM
Ugh. No thank you.

I'd rather not be reading a poor man's version of Bat-MANGA!! every month.
mofo
06-10-2009, 09:45 AM
Kaluta is just filling in for five issues on Mdme X. I would greatly prefer if Hadley stayed on Mdme X-- it's the best DCU book currently being published, in my opinion, even though it's Vertigo-- but if she does move on (or if Mdme X is cancelled), this would be a good book to assign to her.
oh well, cant really say thats a loss

Ugh. No thank you.

I'd rather not be reading a poor man's version of Bat-MANGA!! every month.
have you seen the art? or just commenting on what wikipedia says :smile:? because (in a very objective sense) it's not much different than Frank Quietly's art
Karl O'Neill
06-10-2009, 02:54 PM
I like her art.

I just have zero interest in either of the above mentioned titles.
The Xenos
06-12-2009, 12:14 AM
Ugh. No thank you.

I'd rather not be reading a poor man's version of Bat-MANGA!! every month.

Ugh. Really? Just because she got the unfortunately BS marketing label of one of those OEL-manga artists, that doesn't mean anything about her art. Check out Madam Xanadu's art. It's quite good. Honestly, I don't see anything amerimanga about it.

Now I thought most of those TokyoPop books were crap, most of them using amateur artists and promoting them with a pseudo Japanese stereotype style. You had to dig through the shelves to find something good. Though Eisner nominee Becky Cloonan had a good series that TokyoPop never finished, damn them. Aside from the Japanese manga titles I liked, there were a couple US made books TokyoPop published. Though their marketing was total crap and more of a turn off to me than something to get me to find the good books.

I never checked out Reeder's TokyoPop book among their glut of titles. In hindsight I want to track it down. Her art, along with Wagner's story, is amazing. I never followed the character before, but this is a fascinating book. I wouldn't mind her staying on it for a bit.