Whats your Top 30 favorite X-Artists ??

[Leogam]

List your top 30 favorite artists that have worked on any X-Men related series, here are some of mine.

The X-Men
1) John Byrne
2) John Romita. Jr
3) Arthur Adams
4) Alan Davis
5) Marc Silvestri
6) Jim Lee
7) Andy Kubert
8) Joe Madureira
9) Carlos Pacheco
10) Frank Quitely
11) Ethan Van Sciver
12) Phil Jimenez
13) Tom Raney
14) Salvador Larroca
15) Olivier Coipel
16) Chris Bachalo
17) John Cassaday
18) Billy Tan
19) Terry Dodson

X-Factor
20) Walter Simonson
21) Joe Quesada
22) Ryan Sook

New Mutants/X-Force
23) Sal Buscema
24) Bill Sienkiewicz
25) Brett Blevins
26) Skottie Young
27) Greg Capullo
28) Adam Pollina
29) Clayton Crain

Wolverine/Gambit
30) Steve Skroce

[Bronze Badger]

That's a long-ass list.

In no particular order:

1. Jim Lee
2. Marc Silvestri
3. Chris Bachalo
4. Joe Mad
5. Sal Larocca (X-Treme only)
6. Andy Park (Co-creator of Fat Emma!!)
7. Mike Choi
8. Jan Duursema
9. Jeff Matsuda
10. Skottie Young

[Pixie_Solanas]

1. Paul Smith
2. Jr Jr
3. Paul Smith (again, because he's simply bad-ass)
$. Franko Quitely
5. Chris Bachalo

[Prodigy55]

My top 5.

1. Chris Bachalo
2. Skottie Young
3. Jim Cheung
4. Michael Ryan
5. Mike Choi

[Pixie_Solanas]

Dodson, Tan, and Joe Mad over the understated bravura pencilwork that is PMS? Heresy.

[Home made ectoplasm]

Chris Bachalo
Art Adams
Frank Quitely
Bill Sienkiewicz

I'm not doing 30, sorry.

[marvell2100]

Jimmy
Jim
John
Joe
John
Jim
Joe
John
Adam
Andy
Arthur
Alan
Adam
Steve
Steve
Skottie
Salvador
and Carlos

[NewMutant]

This is essentially a favorite artist list.. a lot of these artist like Coipel, whom I love, did 3 issues of X-Men. Hardly an "X-Men" artist if you ask me.

1) Jim Lee
2) Andy Kubert
3) Marc Silvestri
4) Salvador Larroca
5) John Cassaday
6) John Byrne
7) John Romita. Jr
8) Joe Madureira
9) Carlos Pacheco
10) Chris Bachalo

My top ten X-Men artist in no order.

[peopleofpaper]

I like most of your list the best but Tom Raney. Ugh he ruined UXM with his art. It was like a generic X-men coloring book you can get at the Dollar Store. I couldn't enjoy Psylocke's return because of his art as well as CC's long winded story.

http://psylocke.club.fr/news/pic/uxm460_3.jpg

[Canemacar]

I like most of your list the best but Tom Raney. Ugh he ruined UXM with his art. It was like a generic X-men coloring book you can get at the Dollar Store. I couldn't enjoy Psylocke's return because of his art as well as CC's long winded story.

http://psylocke.club.fr/news/pic/uxm460_3.jpg

Psylocke and X-23 have the exact same pose, right down to the fingers.

[Home made ectoplasm]

Psylocke and X-23 have the exact same pose, right down to the fingers.

Yeah, X-23 was enamoured with Psylocke and was mirroring her throughout those issues. It was a plot point.

[Imraith Nimphais]

Clayton Crain, JR jr., Pacheco, Paul Smith, Sienkiewicz, Silvestri, Simonson, Winsdor-Smith,...(inpoop).

[Fatguy]

30? Even a lover of lists like myself cant bother with THAT large a task. Here's my favorites:

Chris Bachalo
Jim Lee
Marc Silvestri
Whilce Portacio
John Byrne
Art Adams
Alan Davis

[Bronze Badger]

30? Even a lover of lists like myself cant bother with THAT large a task. Here's my favorites:

Chris Bachalo
Jim Lee
Marc Silvestri
Whilce Portacio
John Byrne
Art Adams
Alan Davis

Fatguy are you in a little coat?

[MartinRedmond]

1 Marc Silvestri (80s)
2 JR jr (80s only, not his second DragonBallZ like run)
3 Bill Sienkiewicz
4 Whilce Portacio (X-Factor)
5 Larry Stroman
6 Travel Foreman
7 Humberto Ramos
8 Stuart Immonen
9 Greg Land
10 Igor Kordey

[MartinRedmond]

Psylocke and X-23 have the exact same pose, right down to the fingers.

It's because X23 was playing mimick Psylocke.

[Wildways]

In no real order...

Alan Davis
Chris Bachalo
Salvador Larroca (X-Treme X-Men and Excalibur only)
Marc Silvestri
Skottie Young
Adam Kubert
Joe Mad
Carlos Pacheco
JRJR
Bill Sienkiewicz
Stuart Immonen

Hey, why isn't Liefeld on anyone's list? LOL!

[That JonoGuy]

Here are my top 20 in no particular order.

Andy Kubert
Adam Kubert
Joe Madureira
Carlos Pacheco
Igor Kordey
Olivier Coipel
Chris Bachalo
Terry Dodson
Pablo Raimondi
Bill Sienkiewicz
Skottie Young
Adam Pollina
Steve Skroce
Jim Cheung
Jeff Matsuda
Alan Davis
Salvador Larroca
Sean Phillips
Jim Lee
Steve Epting

[Fatguy]

Fatguy are you in a little coat?

Uhm...yes?

[Bronze Badger]

Uhm...yes?

Tell me you've seen Tommy Boy.

http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=vids.individual&VideoID=4200029

[That JonoGuy]

Stuart Immonen


Has he even worked on an X-Book? I'm drawing a blank.

[Dagger]

Hmmm....this will be tough.

1. Adam Kubert
2. Andy Kubert
3. Art Adams
4. Alan Davis
5. JR Jr.
6. Barry Windsor-Smith
7. Paul Smith
8. John Byrne
9. Dave Cockrum
10. Bill Sienkewicz
11. Walt Simonson
12. Neal Adams
13. Marc Silvestri
14. Joe Mad
15. Whilce Portacio
16. Adam Pollina
17. Chris Bachalo
18. Carlos Pacheco
19. Terry Dodson
20. Ken Lashley
21. Tony Daniel
22. Jim Lee
23. Larry Stroman
24. Sal Buscema
25. Jim Cheung
26. Rob Liefeld (lol)
27. Jan Duursema
28. Paul Chadwick
29. Greg Capullo
30. Al Milgrom

[NewMutant]

Has he even worked on an X-Book? I'm drawing a blank.

ultimate xmen

[psycwave]

In no particular order.

Jim Cheung
Chris Bachalo
Igor Kordey
Alan Davis
Marc Silvistri
Terry Dodson
D. Neves
JR JR
Adam Kubert
Whilce Portacio
Jim Lee

[Flinkman]

i don't really have an ordered list, but i know Chris Bachalo is at the top & i know Paul Ryan, Joe Madureira, Marc Silvestri, John Byrne, John Romita Jr., Skottie Young and Phil Jiminez are all on there.

[Justin K.]

1. Chris Bachalo
2. Ryan Sook
3. Clayton Crain
4. Pablo Raimondi
5. Mike Choi
6. Olivier Coipel
7. Jim Cheung
8. Steve McNiven
9. Terry Dodson
10. Joe Madureira
11. Patrick Zircher
12. Jim Lee
13. Marc Silvestri
14. Valentine DeLandro
15. Phil Jimenez
16. Scott Eaton
17. Diogenes Neves
18. Frank Quitely
19. John Cassaday
20. Paul Smith
21. Mike McKone
22. Humberto Ramos
23. John Romita Jr.
24. Adam Pollina
25. Skottie Young
26. Simone Bianchi
27. Billy Tan
28. Alan Davis
29. Salvador Larroca
30. Khoi Pham

The top 10 though are my Ultimate Favorites...

[Pixie_Solanas]

Hmmm....this will be tough.

30. Al Milgrom

Your Milgrom reference makes my loins tingle.

[Dagger]

Your Milgrom reference makes my loins tingle.
He would have gotten a higher rating had he did more than the Kitty & Wolvie mini. It's still my favorite Wolvie story of all time.

[valentine]

14. David DeLandro



...

Hell, I'll take it.:cool:

[Justin K.]

...

Hell, I'll take it.:cool:

Seeing your name made me realize I got the wrong First name
Used to seeing David above DeLandro on the cover
It threw me off

[Cyclopsj316]

1) Jim Lee
2) Marc Sylvestri
3) Andy Kubert
4) Joe Madueria
5) Whilce Portacio
6) Greg Land
6) John Cassaday
7) Salvador Larocca
8) Adam Kubert
9) Jan Duursema
10) Rob Leifeld. ( x-force... leave me alone !!! lol. )

[Pixie_Solanas]

He would have gotten a higher rating had he did more than the Kitty & Wolvie mini. It's still my favorite Wolvie story of all time.

I love that. I think it was the first tpb I ever bought.

[Dagger]

1) Jim Lee
2) Marc Sylvestri
3) Andy Kubert
4) Joe Madueria
5) Whilce Portacio
6) Greg Land
6) John Cassaday
7) Salvador Larocca
8) Adam Kubert
9) Jan Duursema
10) Rob Leifeld. ( x-force... leave me alone !!! lol. )
The fact that you have Cassaday tied with Land is heresy enough to call for you to be hung by your bowels.

[Pixie_Solanas]

The fact that you have Cassaday tied with Land is heresy enough to call for you to be hung by your bowels.

It's the new paradigm shift. I'm so alt I love Land. Land hating is so mainstream it hurts.

[Justin K.]

It's the new paradigm shift. I'm so alt I love Land. Land hating is so mainstream it hurts.

What does it mean if you like the colorist but not so much the pencils?

[Pixie_Solanas]

What does it mean if you like the colorist but not so much the pencils?

your level of alt has limits.

[Prodigy55]

Agent Torpor, you are so effin hip. Meet me in Williamsburg, bring some PBR.

[Pixie_Solanas]

Agent Torpor, you are so effin hip. Meet me in Williamsburg, bring some PBR.

Williamsburg is soooo 2003, Prod. It's all about Greenpoint now.

[Prodigy55]

Williamsburg is soooo 2003, Prod. It's all about Greenpoint now.

I wouldn't know lol. All we have in Toronto (and maybe all of Canada) is Kensington Market... and it smells bad.

[Pixie_Solanas]

I wouldn't know lol. All we have in all of Canada is Kensington Market... and it smells bad.

You need to decamp to Montreal. The Plateau is so fucking awesome. If I spoke better french, i'd have never left.

[Dagger]

It's the new paradigm shift. I'm so alt I love Land. Land hating is so mainstream it hurts.

Please don't make me love Land.

[Pixie_Solanas]

Please don't make me love Land.

It blows the plebes' minds. They cannot compute. I'm on a whole 'nother level with this.

[That JonoGuy]

What does it mean if you like the colorist but not so much the pencils?

I think it means we need a new thread for favorite X-Colorists! :biggrin:

[Dagger]

It blows the plebes' minds. They cannot compute. I'm on a whole 'nother level with this.
Ugh. I think I'll smoke some pot first, and then try to partake on this soul quest with you.

[Pixie_Solanas]

Ugh. I think I'll smoke some pot first, and then try to partake on this soul quest with you.

Yes, that helps. Admittedly.

You'll thank me later.

[Dagger]

Yes, that helps. Admittedly.

You'll thank me later.
I'll have to dig out my old paraphenalia, and relive my late high school/early college years.

[valentine]

Seeing your name made me realize I got the wrong First name
Used to seeing David above DeLandro on the cover
It threw me off

No worries, it's nice to be included in a random messageboard poll.

[Congo Jack]

Favourite five, no order. Byrne, Smith, Lee, Pacheco, Cassaday.

[Justin K.]

No worries, it's nice to be included in a random messageboard poll.

No problem, enjoying the work done on X-Factor right now
PS Didn't know you were the actual artist at first sight here

[steve2275]

jr jr #1
http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c379/Doggydogg/Colossus%20durablity/Colossusricochetunc300.jpg
art adams is close second
adam kubert third

[Joe Franklin]

No particular order.

Joe Mad.
http://www.herospy.com/wp-content/hero%20spy%202006/Comics/Madureira/xmenjoe.jpg
Jim Lee
http://www.yanowhatimean.com/art/art_jleecmen3.jpg
Marc Silvestri
http://westfieldcomics.com/wow/art/large/MAY072184.jpg
Romita JR
http://www.typingmonkeys.com/Images/uncanny-x-men-210.jpg

[Joe Franklin]

Carlos Pacheco
http://wolverine.x-knights.com/fullsize/wolverine44.jpg
John Byrne
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3121/2736347263_8898b9cc74.jpg
Alan Davis
http://www.popcultureshock.com/papes/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/uncanny-xmen-davis_1024.jpg
Leinil Yu
http://wawong7.home.att.net/collection/YuLeinil_wolverine_cov_sm.jpg

[Vanish]

1. http://static.dossy.org/images/sparkle.gifChris Bachalohttp://static.dossy.org/images/sparkle.gif
2. Frank Quitely
3. Olivier Coipel
4. Bill Sienkiewicz
5. German Garcia

Ryan Sook
Clayton Crain
Ale Garza
(old) Marc Silvestri
Paul Smith
Adam Pollina
Mike Choi
Jim Cheung
Humberto Ramos