Cyclops: Jean or Emma

[the Hornet]

After all these years, if Jean is back from that "room", who do you think Scott is better of with? Your answer does not necessarily mean they are better of with him than any other guy though, so no Scott bashing please. I am just curious to see if the situation has changed from the old "Scott and Jean are the perfect couple" days.

[just another user]

In before thread closure!

[darknessatnoon]

I also wanted to get my two cents in.

Jean is garbage. She's not coming back. Scott already has the best. Why would he downgrade for tail that he's already had?

[Steven F.]

I vote Emma cause Jean is too good for Cyclops. WHEN she comes back, I don't want my favorite character anywhere near Cyclops.

[Shaka]

Jean and Scott were boring

[Optic Rage!]

No....NOoo....NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

Cronin....DO SOMETHING.

Also, Emma>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.Jean.

FOREVER.

[MartinRedmond]

Jean's too good for Scott. Scott deserves second best Jean wannabe trash. Emma's purrrrrrfect.

Emma=Dollarstore Jean

[Wind Rider]

See..... this is just wrong.... another closure is coming.....

Scott and Emma forever!

Jean deserves better :tongue:

[worstblogever]

Ah, this thread will end in fire.

http://gallery.hd.org/_exhibits/natural-science/_more2004/_more10/bonfire-fire-inferno-heart-red-orange-yellow-1-DHD.jpg

[The Thunderbird]

While I don't Jean to become an uber-powerful goddess, I don't want her to become somebody's arm-candy either. I love Jean a lot, but Jean and Emma should never be compared, ever. They're no more similar than Colossus and Wolverine.

I wonder what would last longer; this thread, or a guy who pissed off Sabretooth?

[Omega Alpha]

Good to see a thread that is very original and asks something we never have before for once.

[just another user]

So, who thinks Bishop is African American, and who thinks he's an aborigine?

Also, Iceman - a bit gay?

[That JonoGuy]

I think Emma is a much better fit for Scott. Although I think any women that gets involved with Scott is in for trouble.

[Wind-Breaker]

http://i39.tinypic.com/24mc4ed.jpg

[Optic Rage!]

So, who thinks Bishop is African American, and who thinks he's an aborigine?

Also, Iceman - a bit gay?

Here's some more.

Storm vs Cyclops...who is the better leader?

Grant Morrisons Magneto...the best ever?

Lorna Dane...Dull or Fun?

Do you count Sage as one of the members of the O6?

Should Jean stay dead?

Should Rachel die?

Is Vulcan cool?

X-Men Legacy: Only for smart people?

Is X-Force RIGHT??

[RickyD410]

I've never actually read a comic with Cyke and Jean when they were together. So I cant really judge. I do know that I really don't like Emma, and I do like Jean quite a bit. So my preference would be Jean. But I dont think they can get back together if/when she comes back. It'd just be really, really weird and awkward. Plus, he's kinda devoted to Emma right now.

Its a very sticky situation. But I dont think Scott will leave Emma for Jean if/when she comes back. I think/hope he's learned from his mistakes. After he left Maddie for Jean, Maddie became the Goblyn Queen. After he cheated on Jean with Emma, Jean died. Seriously, the dude has to have learned by now that cheating is NOT a good thing!

[just another user]

I've never actually read a comic with Cyke and Jean when they were together. So I cant really judge. I do know that I really don't like Emma, and I do like Jean quite a bit. So my preference would be Jean. But I dont think they can get back together if/when she comes back. It'd just be really, really weird and awkward. Plus, he's kinda devoted to Emma right now.

Its a very sticky situation. But I dont think Scott will leave Emma for Jean if/when she comes back. I think/hope he's learned from his mistakes. After he left Maddie for Jean, Maddie became the Goblyn Queen. After he cheated on Jean with Emma, Jean died. Seriously, the dude has to have learned by now that cheating is NOT a good thing!

Theres no point answering seriously when the thread is about to be deleted.

[Brian Cronin]

In before thread closure!

Hehe...I like that.

-Brian