Rank the FC LSes

[Samy]

Put the four following series in order of preference. The one you like the most at the top. The one you like least at the bottom. Also, add a school grade (A to D, or F) at the end of each.

LEGION OF THREE WORLDS (A+)
ROGUES REVENGE (A)
FINAL CRISIS (C)
REVELATIONS (C-)

[carabas]

Hmm...

Final Crisis: A+
Superman Beyond: A+
Revelations: A
Rogues Revenge: A
Legion Of Three worlds: B+
Requim: C+
Last Will and Testimoney: C-
Death Of The New Gods: D
Countdown: F

[Magneto Rocks]

Final Crisis: A+
Superman Beyond: A+
Revelations: B
Rogues Revenge: A
Legion Of Three worlds: B-
Requim: B+
Last Will and Testimoney: F
Death Of The New Gods: C -
Countdown: D

[Karl O'Neill]

Final Crisis A+
Rogues revenge A
legion of 3 worlds B+
Revelations C
DCU #0 B
Last will and Testement B-
Submit B

Requiem A

[mofo]

Final Crisis: A+ (issue 4 ended with a bang!)
Superman Beyond: B (because it took me a while to understand)
Revelations: C (its all right, i prefer not to be accosted by religious thematics in my stories)
Rogues Revenge: B+ (awesome artwork!)
Legion Of Three worlds: C+ (have always bee confused when it comes to Legion stories)
Requiem: B (got a little cliched)
Last Will and Testament: D (been there, done that....except for the Deathstroke shit)
Death Of The New Gods: Z (is there such a grade?)
Countdown: Z- (waste of my YEAR)

[Batman was taken]

Final Crisis - A+ (I'm loving it)
Final Crisis: Revelations - A (The religious undertones don't bug me, and I find that it's been VERY well written)
Final Crisis: Requiem - A (Good closure to the MM story)
Final Crisis: Submit - A- (Pretty good)
Final Crisis: Legion of Three Worlds - A- (maybe the story is hurt for me by knowing all of three legionnaires:tongue: But, it is GJ, and the story has made up for that)
Final Crisis: Rogues' Revenge - B+ (Solid story, the end just kinda... I don't know.)
DC Universe #0 - B- (Just set up, not much of a story...)
DC Universe: Last Will and Testament - C (Been there, done that. And I thought the "triangle" between Batman and his kids was... poor characterization.)
Final Crisis: Superman Beyond - D (maybe I need to read it again...:confused: And the 3D gave me a headache)

[Mon-el]

I've only read a few, and I'm probably a bit harsh on my rankings.

Final Crisis: Legion of Three Worlds - A+++++++
Final Crisis - A -
Final Crisis: Rogues' Revenge - B+
DC Universe: Last Will and Testament - D
Final Crisis: Superman Beyond - C+

[Ghost Shark]

Final Crisis: A+
Superman Beyond: C
Revelations: A-
Submit: B+
Rogues Revenge: A
Legion Of Three worlds: A+
Requiem: B
Last Will and Testimony: F
Death Of The New Gods: I, for I wish I hadn't read this insult to Kirby!
Countdown: Does it count if you flip through the individual issues in the store, groan, then put them back?

[Capt USA]

Final Crisis (so far) B-
Rogues Revenge A
Superman Beyond D- (being generous here)
Last Will and Testament B-
Legion of 3 worlds B+
Revelations C+(maybe B-)

Countdown Piper and Trickster parts before Darkseid A+, Jimmy Olsen part before Darkseid C, the rest of the Series I've blacked out of my mind.

Didn't even consider the Red Lantern option (sorry but the concept is so monumentally stupid that there is no way I could justify spending money on it, at least the yellow lanterns had the anti-matter universe origin or something that made almost sense)

[Kuma]

Final Crisis A
LOTW A
Revelations A
Rogues Revenge A
Superman Beyond B+ (only because its so long between issue 1 and 2)
Resist B+
Requiem C
Last will D
Countdown D-
DOTNG FFFFFFFF

[Kuma]

double post, sorry

[Sean Walsh]

Final Crisis A
Requiem A-
Rogues Revenge A-
Legion of 3 Worlds B+
Superman Beyond B+
Last Will & Testament B+
Resist B+
Revelations B
Countdown D
DOTNG D-

[AbsurdistEmergence]

Final Crisis A
Rogue's Revenge A
Legion of Three Worlds A -
Superman Beyond A -
Rage of the Red Lanterns B +
Submit B +
Requiem B
Last Will & Testament B - (could be a C+ or a C - really not sure)

I'm not reading Revelations and didn't read Countdown or Death of the New Gods.

Obviously I am really enjoying Final Crisis and its tie-ins. I think Morrison is writing a big (and crazy) story, while Johns is writing very interesting tie-ins.

[Scott Taylor]

Rogues Revenge, FC, and Legion of Three Worlds A
Requiem A-
Revelations B+
Superman Beyond B-
Submit C
Rage of Red Lanterns C-

Everything else was poop.

[Calvin Government]

Final Crisis: A
Superman Beyond: A
Revelations: A-
Submit: B+
Rogues Revenge: B
Requiem: C
Last Will and Testament: C
Rage of the Red Lanterns: C-
Legion Of Three worlds: D+