How many more X-Books are you getting post-Messiah CompleX?

[Sentinel K]

So, with the new status quo and some new X-books out there after messiah complex, how many more titles are you picking up now?

[psycwave]

So I assume this poll is in contrast to how many books we have dropped thread...

[Imraith Nimphais]

Just the one...The Par-X-cellence, X-force!

[Pach!]

I picked up Young X-men, Cable and X-force.

[darknessatnoon]

Does the number of people who look at this thread also count in the statistical analysis?

[Sentinel K]

I'm not pretending that this thread is in any way accurate as to what people are buying.

I just think that the other side of the coin needed to be represented.

[timbox]

This poll is biased as there is no option for "ALL"

[just another user]

This poll is not fair as it includes an option for "The same as before"

[Pach!]

This poll is slanted to the right

[timbox]

Does the number of people who look at this thread also count in the statistical analysis?

This is a great point and should be explored further.

[just another user]

I am at a loss to explain how this poll seems to be contradicting a similar poll on the first page. People are buying more and less books at the same time?



I

[drwho]

I dont think many will read the topic of the poll much. Notice it says how many MORE are you getting than before rather than how many you are getting all together.

[frog]

Does the number of people who look at this thread also count in the statistical analysis?

This is a great point and should be explored further.

The number of people that don't look also count.

[Sentinel K]

I dont think many will read the topic of the poll much. Notice it says how many more are you getting than before rather than how many you are getting all together.

Most people aren't idiots.

[psycwave]

Does the number of people who look at this thread also count in the statistical analysis?

This is a great point and should be explored further.

The number of people that don't look also count.

What about the people who skim

[drwho]

So HI-FI per the poll it said you are buying 5 more x-titles than before since messiah. Is that really true?

[timbox]

This is the worst poll in all of my 7 months of poll taking experience.

[pryde15]

So HI-FI per the poll it said you are buying 5 more x-titles than before since messiah. Is that really true?

Does it honestly matter?

[Pach!]

So HI-FI per the poll it said you are buying 5 more x-titles than before since messiah. Is that really true?

LOL. this thread is entertaining

[drwho]

Does it honestly matter?

Well I find it hard to believe that one storyline caused someone to buy 5 more books than before.

[Askani's Flame]

I'm currently getting two more, but am highly considering dropping Cable for it's shear lack of anything good.

[Josef F.]

What about the VIEWS.
we haven't discussed how many views this thread has had.
It is important!

[timbox]

I voted 5 only because there was no option for "ALL" or "13."

[pryde15]

Well I find it hard to believe that one storyline caused someone to buy 5 more books than before.

Well I find it hard to believe that one storyline caused someone to drop all the books. But I don't go questioning them in your thread.

[drwho]

Guess people are already voting on the poll wrong like I said they would. Bad stories lead to book dropping. I said 4 and gave my reasons lol. Read the first post of a thread and there would not be this type of misunderstanding.

[Pach!]

Guess people are already voting on the poll wrong. I said 4 and gave my reasons lol.

Perhaps when the poll is closed Pete will perform a t-test to see the accuracy! Otherwise Marvel might have to not take a CBR poll seriously and that would just be a tragedy

[pryde15]

Guess people are already voting on the poll wrong. Bad stories lead to book dropping. I said 4 and gave my reasons lol. Read the first post of a thread and there would not be this type of misunderstanding.

But yet you find it hard to believe someone picked them all up because they enjoyed the storyline? True, Messiah Complex wasn't great, but I have enjoyed the direction the books have taken.

[Steven F.]

I am enjoying this thread so much!

BTW, Messiah Complex rocked.

[Sentinel K]

Guess people are already voting on the poll wrong like I said they would. Bad stories lead to book dropping. I said 4 and gave my reasons lol. Read the first post of a thread and there would not be this type of misunderstanding.

Boo-hoo.

Both these threads are horse shit.

That's the only reason i created it. To illustrate how inaccurate your thread is.

[drwho]

Boo-hoo.

Both these threads are horse shit.

That's the only reason i created it. To illustrate how inaccurate your thread is.

This poll is flawed because people are voting how many books they buy rather than how many more they buy. I do not have to be Emma Frost to see that. :wink:

And if one thread was so bad why make another one to take up space on the board?

[Josef F.]

According to the amount of views, added to the tangential dirigible of the Axis line of The voting mainframe shows us that comic sales have gone up bt 26.758386%
This coinciding with the factual 7% drop in comics, means that I'm great.

[timbox]

Boo-hoo.

Both these threads are horse shit.

That's the only reason i created it. To illustrate how inaccurate your thread is.

Does Sentinel K need his mouth washed out with soap?

[psycwave]

This poll is flawed because people are voting how many books they buy rather than how many more they buy. I do not have to be Emma Frost to see that. :wink:

And if one thread was so bad why make another one to take up space on the board?

Really because i voted on how many more as I thought the others were. I mean the question is pretty clear. It asks how many more are you buying and that is what everyone seems to be answering.

[Sentinel K]

This poll is flawed because people are voting how many books they buy rather than how many more they buy. I do not have to be Emma Frost to see that. :wink:

And if one thread was so bad why make another one to take up space on the board?

No. You think that simply because YOU don't like the books and think that everyone else should think the same.

You have no evidence that says that people aren't buying 5 more books than before. Even if they aren't.

Cos I'm a massive ****. That's why.

[Maestro]

I know I'm reading X-Force.

[pryde15]

Does Sentinel K need his mouth washed out with soap?

Your clever mocking of Kitty Pryde will be to no avail timbox!

Sorry I have wanted to use avail in a sentence today, and it felt like a good moment.

[Steven F.]

WOW...something this week must have been AMAZINGLY good...looking at how many VIEWS this thread has, and how fast it is catching up with the older poll...This is just proving how much something must have been fantastic yesterday, meaning everyone has started picking more books up. Obviously. I mean, look at the views of this thread!

[timbox]

Your clever mocking of Kitty Pryde will be to no avail timbox!

Sorry I have wanted to use avail in a sentence today, and it felt like a good moment.

How rude!!!!

[pryde15]

How rude!!!!

:eek:

YOU FILTHY WHORE. Prepare for anti Surge signs! I did it to La Fea, it's now your turn. :mad:

[timbox]

:eek:

YOU FILTHY WHORE. Prepare for anti Surge signs! I did it to La Fea, it's now your turn. :mad:

Anti-Surge signs only make me love her more.

[pryde15]

Anti-Surge signs only make me love her more.

Even with scans of her being murdered? It shouldn't be that hard to find.

[matthewaos]

Awesome thread!

During MC I was reading all for books, before it (and endangered species) I wasn't reading UXM or NXm. With DWS I was reading everything, except YXM. I now dropped Wolverine, I was buying it for Aaron. I don't read first class, I didn't get the Colossus origin, and the only "origin" I'm getting is Beast, at the moment. I dropped AXM during Whedon and now I start again for Ellis. I dropped Origins a long way ago, and I'll be reading again only for the crossover. I am sure trying Deadpool. Is there anything else?

[Imraith Nimphais]

Wot might just be interesting is the end-result overall combined percentage correllation as to wot was dropped/picked up...e.g. I collected only 4 titles pre-MC but dropped 3 AND picked up 1, post-MC...so currently, all i'm collecting are 2 x-books...someone else may have collected 6, dropped none and picked up 4...so their overall tally would be 10...you catch my drift...good luck to the poor beast who takes up that challenge (I'll buy the excedrine gel-tabs and/or the loaded magnum 45)...but it could be interesting.

[psycwave]

We also must take into consideration what was picked up and then dropped. As many people have done with Cable and Young X-men

[Imraith Nimphais]

yes...exactly.

[claimtosubclaim]

Well I find it hard to believe that one storyline caused someone to buy 5 more books than before.

Why? I've added X-Force, Uncanny, Legacy (if you count it as being a different book from Adjectiveless), the Divided We Stand one-shots, and I'm going to be picking up Astonishing X-Men: Second Stage when it comes out. I also still read X-Factor and First Class.

[Dan'L]

Does New Warriors count as an X-title?

-Dan'L

[metalgorgomon]

Pre-MC, i collected Astonishing, Uncanny, X-Men, Exiles, X-Factor (tpb).

Post-MC, i've been collecting Uncanny, Legacy, New Exiles, Young X-Men, GeNext, X-Force, (and going to get) Astonishing 2nd .
I sorta dropped X-Factor, since I won't be picking up the Arcade Arc Tpb, but most probably will pick up X-Factor starting #33.

I (sorta) dropped 1 book, but gained 3 more. So post MC, I've been collecting 2 more X-books.

[psycwave]

Does New Warriors count as an X-title?

-Dan'L

NO........

[scouse mouse]

I voted 1, as I added Uncanny to X Factor and Carey's X book. Then I remembered I'm going to give Astonishing a try so it should be 2.

[insidemyhead]

Well I find it hard to believe that one storyline caused someone to buy 5 more books than before.

That's not what the poll says. It's asking how many more books are you picking up since MC, not how many more books are you picking up BECAUSE of MC.

[Dizzy D]

2 more, 3 if we count Captain Britain. And with Astonishing probably going on a slightly more regular schedule now, I believe the net-gain will be even bigger.

[jarrod]

Um... two?

Pre-MX
-Astonishing X-Men
-New Excalibur
-New X-Men
-Uncanny X-Men
-Wolverine (sometimes)
-X-Factor
-X-Men

Post-MX
-Astonishing X-Men
-Captain Britain & MI:13
-Uncanny X-Men
-Wolverine (sometimes)
-Wolverine: Fist Class
-X-Factor
-X-Force
-X-Men Legacy
-Young X-Men

[Judge Mental]

I'm picking up the same.

I tried Young Avengers but didn't like it.

Cable just didn't appeal to me, even though I liked Cable & Deadpool.

[Gene M.]

I've added Cable and X-Force since MC ended. X-Force is awesome, Cable is getting the benefit of the doubt that it will pick up in the second arc.

[Seikun21]

I'm picking up the same.

I tried Young Avengers but didn't like it.

Cable just didn't appeal to me, even though I liked Cable & Deadpool.

I think you mean Young X-men.

[Judge Mental]

I think you mean Young X-men.

D'oh!

Of course.