PDA

View Full Version : X-Men First Class (Vol. 2) #5 Summary/Review/*Spoilers*


caney
10-24-2007, 04:51 PM
X-Men First Class (Vol. 2) #5
Writer - Jeff Parker
Artist - Roger Cruz

As always, this issue of First Class opens with a fun little recap page, this time including a note from Hank to Robert and Warren regarding the proper care of his comics along with the replies from Bobby and War.

The main story itself opens with the X-Men on assignment helping the Army search for the Hulk in the wilderness of Colorado. The Hulk ends up finding the X-Men, and not surprisingly, lets them know he just wants to be left alone. Most of this issue is one long fight scene between the Hulk (noticeably holding back from killing the kids as he just wants them to leave him alone) and the X-Men (attempting to subdue the Hulk). Eventually, Rick Jones shows up and tries to stop the X-Men from attacking the Hulk after letting them know how the Hulk saved his life; however by this time the Hulk is to enraged to be calmed down. When all hope seems lost Xavier, who was coordinating the X-Men's efforts with the Army at a remote base, is able to gain control of the Hulk's mind and calm him down so that he reverts back to Bruce Banner (who Hank is awesomed by, lol). In the end Xavier learns that the Army only wants to capture the Hulk so they can use him as a weapon, so the X-Men decided to leave Banner and Jones where they are and pretend they never found the Hulk.

Definitely not my favorite issue of the series by a long shot, but it had it's fun little moments. If you want to read an all out brawl between the X-Men and the Hulk, World War Hulk: X-Men delivers much better on that note. I'd give this issue a 3 out of 5. Still, this is a book I look forward to greatly every month!

The issue also featured a couple quick backup stories. The first backup teams up Jeff "Paranormal" Parker with Colleen "Creepy" Coover again for a very fun little Halloweenish 2-page tale. Super super cute and funny, this was the highlight of the issue for me (5 out of 5 for this quick vignette). :D

The second backup is a Mini Marvels tale by Chris Giarrusso. Also cute, but it doesn't feature the O5 (it's about Johnny Storm interviewing to join the X-Men), so, who really cares? ;)

rilokyle
10-24-2007, 04:56 PM
This book sounds more and more like Archie & Friends then an x-book. Just sayin'.

Brian M.
10-24-2007, 06:03 PM
Sounds great to me. I'm a sucker for the O5 and I'll always love anything w/ them in it. I don't care if it's written by Austen and drawn by Liefeld. I look forward to it.

Diablito
10-24-2007, 07:02 PM
LOL, Johhny Storm is being interviewed to join the X-Men? What??

Hi-Fi
10-24-2007, 07:41 PM
The second backup is a Mini Marvels tale by Chris Giarrusso. Also cute, but it doesn't feature the O5 (it's about Johnny Storm interviewing to join the X-Men), so, who really cares? ;)
It features Rogue, though! :evilangry

But yeah, the Halloween tale was the best and cutest thing ever.

Volk1
10-24-2007, 08:20 PM
Yeah I really liked the backup tale with Xavier pulling the prank the best story of the issue.

The main story was a letdown of sorts. The artist for the second story should be the main artist - I would not mind at all if that was the art for First Class.

Omega Alpha
10-24-2007, 08:26 PM
This book sounds more and more like Archie & Friends then an x-book. Just sayin'.

I hope Polaris and Havok are killed by Vulcan and never return :p

Anyway, X-men vs Hulk, and touching the way both are seen by other people, is one of those stories that you wonder how come no one ever did before in 45 years. And while i like the issue, i think it would be more appropriate to a book that was not an all ages one like this.

But the Halloween story was hilarious, as well as Johnny Storm's interview to join the X-men.

Faded
10-24-2007, 08:27 PM
SCANS?

_daily?

caney
10-24-2007, 08:29 PM
It features Rogue, though! :evilangry


She should have just grabbed him and fixed her problem like that. That would teach him.

Brian M.
10-24-2007, 08:42 PM
I hope Polaris and Havok are killed by Vulcan and never return :p

Anyway, X-men vs Hulk, and touching the way both are seen by other people, is one of those stories that you wonder how come no one ever did before in 45 years. And while i like the issue, i think it would be more appropriate to a book that was not an all ages one like this.

But the Halloween story was hilarious, as well as Johnny Storm's interview to join the X-men.

Do you enjoy trying to bait folks? Or does acting like a 9yr old w/ new internet access make you feel good?

We R. Venom
10-24-2007, 08:46 PM
Yeah i am definitely picking this up ASAP. One of the best books out! With J. Storm in it? What? Theres no way i'll pass it up.

rilokyle
10-24-2007, 08:48 PM
I hope Polaris and Havok are killed by Vulcan and never return :p


I WILL lay down my pimphand if you ever say that again. :evilsmile

Rubicant
10-25-2007, 10:47 AM
Sounds great to me. I'm a sucker for the O5 and I'll always love anything w/ them in it. I don't care if it's written by Austen and drawn by Liefeld. I look forward to it.

That sounds like a creative team dare.

Hi-Fi
10-25-2007, 02:57 PM
Do you enjoy trying to bait folks? Or does acting like a 9yr old w/ new internet access make you feel good?
Brian, how was that baiting? He was just joking around because Kyle made a joke about the book. Seriously, not EVERYTHING is bait.

Brian M.
10-25-2007, 08:40 PM
So I finally read the issue and it's good, my only complaint is the Hulk. Too much Hulk I think going around Marvel these days. First Class is great b/c it's not doing what other books are doing and this is the only issue where I really wasn't into the story. The character interaction was great and it was nice seeing the X-Men not get smashed around all the time, but still...Hulk...no thanks. I look forward to the next couple of issues as I really enjoyed the last two part series.

drwho
10-25-2007, 11:20 PM
I felt this issue was pretty dry, boring, and bad. Even the Hulk didn't seem like the Hulk to me and the art suffered. Also they should at least pay some homage to past stories. I mean what happened to the team needing secret ids. They are talking to everyone maskless not caring. Worst issue so far with probably the potential storywise to have been one of the best.

steve2275
10-26-2007, 01:03 AM
LOL, Johhny Storm is being interviewed to join the X-Men? What??

answer
priceless :p

Diablito
10-27-2007, 07:28 PM
Ok, I know I'm late, but I want to know: did Johnny Storm make it into the X-Men in the interview? Thanks!

Brian M.
10-27-2007, 07:31 PM
Ok, I know I'm late, but I want to know: did Johnny Storm make it into the X-Men in the interview? Thanks!

Firestar and Sunfire showed up. Quota filled.

Brett P
10-27-2007, 07:43 PM
I have about 3 issues sitting in my cupboard unread...never seem to get around to it, always have half a pile that I'm behind with...the trouble with online ordering and ahving to order 3 months in advance...if u wanna drop something u gota carry on recieving for the 2-3 months previous that u ordered..

Diablito
10-27-2007, 07:50 PM
Firestar and Sunfire showed up. Quota filled.

WHATTT!!!! My heart is pounding! Did this really happen?




I loves me some pyro heroes...

drwho
10-27-2007, 07:55 PM
You do realize they are talking about the mini marvel one page stories that get put out? Sad thing is that was the best part of this issue.

Diablito
10-27-2007, 08:24 PM
You do realize they are talking about the mini marvel one page stories that get put out? Sad thing is that was the best part of this issue.

Haha, yeah I'm fully aware that section was short. However, I have a lot of love for pyrokinetics, and I really love it when new people join the X-Men, so I wanted to know if anything big happened.