Who would win in a fight, Iceman or Cyclops?

[MyMomThinksImCool]

Given the past tension between Bobby and Scott and then factoring in their confrontation in 204 if they were to throw down, who would come out on top?

[jarrod]

Depends on the circumstances really... usually I'd say Bobby thanks to his vastly more capable powerset, but depending on circumstances, Scott's certainly clever enough to use the field and other factors to his advantage.

[DaeJi]

Am I the only one who sees this ending in sex? Also, this should probably be on the Rumble Boards.

[The Lucky One]

This'll get moved to the Rumbles thread in about 5 minutes, but it's Cyclops. Bobby has more power, but he's nowhere near the tactician or fighter Scott is. Scott fires one shot at the wall 5 feet to Bobby's right, Bobby laughs at how much his aim is off, and then the ricochet to the back of his head tags him. Fight over.

Or if it were no powers, hand-to-hand, Scott would dominate.

-D

[Mitsaso]

...who would come out on top?

Scott would dominate.


This thread is tottally horny. :evilsmile

[Askani's Flame]

Bobby for the win. Bobby freezes all the water molecules in Scott's body before Scott even a shot out.

[pariah-1972]

As much as i hate to admit it it would probably be Cyclops just for the simple fact that bobby is always holding back and would do so especially if he was fighting someone who was a friend.
this doesn't mean whos more powerfull at all just who is a better fighter.

[DaeJi]

Scott even a shot out.
This thread is tottally horny. :evilsmile

It seems I'm not the only one.

[The Lucky One]

This thread is tottally horny. :evilsmile

No, I think that's just you, dear.

-D

[DeadMuskrat]

Anyone who thinks Bobby could beat Scott is kidding themselves. Bobby is too weak minded to take someone of Scott's caliber down.